Will YOU buy the new MSG set?

Post by **RonBaker2003** » Fri Jul 27, 2012 6:37 pm

Two different packages with the same shows in racks at the same time. The general public would go for the cheaper of the two and sales would suffer for both packages. I don't think Sony would make such a marketing mistake. Besides, the "Afternoon in the Garden" cd is still in the racks and still selling. And from all accounts the original mix on the MSG evening concert is awful. Haven't played my LP in a long time, so I can't tell about that. Why would anyone want a remaster of an awful mix?

Post by **Rich_TCB** » Fri Jul 27, 2012 6:40 pm

Well I'll just say this. Vic Anesini did a wonderful job remastering the MSG show on the CM box set - it sounds fantastic. So I don't think the general public will have a problem with the sound quality.

poormadpeter · Post by **poormadpeter** » Fri Jul 27, 2012 6:42 pm

When Legacy released the Cash San Quentin concert (or was it Folsom Prison - one or the other), there were two different editions - one with and one without the DVD. The packaging looks similar to the current re-release of the 4cd nbc tv special set.

Post by **elvisland** » Fri Jul 27, 2012 6:47 pm

oh yes cant wait

Post by **debtd1** » Fri Jul 27, 2012 7:30 pm

Pete Dube wrote:For those who are confused by the recording terminology being used in this thread I offer the following:

A multi-track tape is the original tape that Elvis and the musicians recorded onto in the studio (including overdubs) and on stage. In the 70's this was usually a 16 track tape. It is this multi-track tape that gets mixed (or re-mixed). It is then transferred to a stereo master tape from which the records are cut. Stereo master tapes cannot be re-mixed, only re-mastered. I hope this helps.

thanks for that....I know nothing about the technical stuff you guys are talking about......so any useful info greatly appreciated;)

Post by **Justin** » Fri Jul 27, 2012 8:08 pm

I think it's great Sony will play it safe and will be offering two versions of the product. I understand a few would want the evening show remastered with its original mix but a part of me also wants the evening show's new, fresher sound to to be availalbe to the casual fan who picks up the 2 disk version also.

Post by **Elvis2001.net** » Fri Jul 27, 2012 8:38 pm

here is an advert that's inside the I Am An Elvis Fan release.

Post by **JimmyCool** » Fri Jul 27, 2012 8:46 pm

I like it in black & white.

Post by **Hans** » Fri Jul 27, 2012 8:51 pm

It seems I have to buy the shows twice ...... looks very promising ... I want it all..!!!!

Post by **Justin** » Fri Jul 27, 2012 8:54 pm

Thanks for posting the ad.

I assume the 2 Disc Legacy Edition will have the original artwork for the evening show used on the front, leaving the new artwork only for the special edition 3 Disc "Prince From Another Planet" release?

Post by **RonBaker2003** » Fri Jul 27, 2012 9:04 pm

I don't need the Legacy release, but I will definitely buy "Prince from Another Planet" to get the newly remixed concerts (and DVD).

Post by **Pete Dube** » Fri Jul 27, 2012 9:26 pm

debtd1 wrote:
Pete Dube wrote:For those who are confused by the recording terminology being used in this thread I offer the following:

A multi-track tape is the original tape that Elvis and the musicians recorded onto in the studio (including overdubs) and on stage. In the 70's this was usually a 16 track tape. It is this multi-track tape that gets mixed (or re-mixed). It is then transferred to a stereo master tape from which the records are cut. Stereo master tapes cannot be re-mixed, only re-mastered. I hope this helps.

thanks for that....I know nothing about the technical stuff you guys are talking about......so any useful info greatly appreciated;)

You're quite welcome!

Post by **TCB-FAN** » Fri Jul 27, 2012 10:03 pm

So the 2 CD Legacy Edition is not re-mixed , but the 3 Disc package is ?

Post by **Rich_TCB** » Fri Jul 27, 2012 10:04 pm

That is correct.

Post by **Pete Dube** » Fri Jul 27, 2012 10:21 pm

TCB-FAN wrote:So the 2 CD Legacy Edition is not re-mixed , but the 3 Disc package is ?

The re-mix is a selling point or marketing hook aimed at us hardcores as incentive to get us to shell out the bucks for this set.

Post by **Good Time Charlie** » Fri Jul 27, 2012 10:38 pm

Pete Dube wrote:
TCB-FAN wrote:So the 2 CD Legacy Edition is not re-mixed , but the 3 Disc package is ?
The re-mix is a selling point or marketing hook aimed at us hardcores as incentive to get us to shell out the bucks for this set.

No it is not. Why are there so many people always trying to put a negative slant on Sony's releases?

If they hadn't remixed the concerts, and just given us a remaster of the original mix, you would have probably moaned that the mix was in need of an upgrade.

Post by **debtd1** » Fri Jul 27, 2012 10:51 pm

RonBaker2003 wrote:I don't need the Legacy release, but I will definitely buy "Prince from Another Planet" to get the newly remixed concerts (and DVD).

me too.....looking forward to this

Post by **JimmyCool** » Fri Jul 27, 2012 11:09 pm

debtd1 wrote:
RonBaker2003 wrote:I don't need the Legacy release, but I will definitely buy "Prince from Another Planet" to get the newly remixed concerts (and DVD).
me too.....looking forward to this

Me too! I'm not excited about the DVD though.

Post by **Pete Dube** » Fri Jul 27, 2012 11:51 pm

Good Time Charlie wrote:
Pete Dube wrote:
TCB-FAN wrote:So the 2 CD Legacy Edition is not re-mixed , but the 3 Disc package is ?
The re-mix is a selling point or marketing hook aimed at us hardcores as incentive to get us to shell out the bucks for this set.
No it is not. Why are there so many people always trying to put a negative slant on Sony's releases?

If they hadn't remixed the concerts, and just given us a remaster of the original mix, you would have probably moaned that the mix was in need of an upgrade.

Huh? Charlie, what "negative slant" are you talking about? The re-mix is in fact a selling point for the hardcore fans. And that's a good thing!

Post by **Good Time Charlie** » Sat Jul 28, 2012 12:47 am

Pete Dube wrote:
Good Time Charlie wrote:
Pete Dube wrote:
TCB-FAN wrote:So the 2 CD Legacy Edition is not re-mixed , but the 3 Disc package is ?
The re-mix is a selling point or marketing hook aimed at us hardcores as incentive to get us to shell out the bucks for this set.
No it is not. Why are there so many people always trying to put a negative slant on Sony's releases?

If they hadn't remixed the concerts, and just given us a remaster of the original mix, you would have probably moaned that the mix was in need of an upgrade.
Huh? Charlie, what "negative slant" are you talking about? The re-mix is in fact a selling point for the hardcore fans. And that's a good thing!

Sorry Pete, I thought you was saying it a negative way!

The way you've worded that, it sounds like you are complaining.

I'm just so used to it around here.

Post by **JimmyCool** » Sat Jul 28, 2012 12:53 am

Good Time Charlie wrote:Sorry Pete, I thought you was saying it a negative way!
The way you've worded that, it sounds like you are complaining.
I'm just so used to it around here.

Maybe we are all misunderstanding Tony.. too?

Post by **Steve Morse** » Sat Jul 28, 2012 1:09 am

JimmyCool wrote:I like it in black & white.

+1
Front cover, that is . . . maybe back cover, too.

Steve Morse

Post by **Good Time Charlie** » Sat Jul 28, 2012 1:39 am

JimmyCool wrote:
Good Time Charlie wrote:Sorry Pete, I thought you was saying it a negative way!
The way you've worded that, it sounds like you are complaining.
I'm just so used to it around here.

Maybe we are all misunderstanding Tony.. too?

Haha.

You know, genuinely my first thought was that Pete had turned into Tony..

Post by **Pete Dube** » Sat Jul 28, 2012 4:18 am

Good Time Charlie wrote:
JimmyCool wrote:
Good Time Charlie wrote:Sorry Pete, I thought you was saying it a negative way!
The way you've worded that, it sounds like you are complaining.
I'm just so used to it around here.

Maybe we are all misunderstanding Tony.. too?
Haha.

You know, genuinely my first thought was that Pete had turned into Tony..

Charlie, if you're gonna turn me into someone how about Justin Timberlake?
That pipsqueak's gettin' more poon tang than Errol Flynn! Must be hung like a Clydesdale.

Matthew · Post by **Matthew** » Sat Jul 28, 2012 4:26 am

JimmyCool wrote:Maybe we are all misunderstanding Tony.. too?

You're right, maybe all the ceaseless grumbling and negativity is just a guy trying to be "truthful"?

Naaaaaah!

For Elvis CD Collectors

Will YOU buy the new MSG set?

Will YOU buy the new MSG set?

Re: Will YOU buy the new MSG set?

Re: Will YOU buy the new MSG set?

Re: Will YOU buy the new MSG set?

Re: Will YOU buy the new MSG set?

Re: Will YOU buy the new MSG set?

Re: Will YOU buy the new MSG set?

Re: Will YOU buy the new MSG set?

Re: Will YOU buy the new MSG set?

Re: Will YOU buy the new MSG set?

Re: Will YOU buy the new MSG set?

Re: Will YOU buy the new MSG set?

Re: Will YOU buy the new MSG set?

Re: Will YOU buy the new MSG set?

Re: Will YOU buy the new MSG set?

Re: Will YOU buy the new MSG set?

Re: Will YOU buy the new MSG set?

Re: Will YOU buy the new MSG set?

Re: Will YOU buy the new MSG set?

Re: Will YOU buy the new MSG set?

Re: Will YOU buy the new MSG set?

Re: Will YOU buy the new MSG set?

Re: Will YOU buy the new MSG set?

Re: Will YOU buy the new MSG set?

Re: Will YOU buy the new MSG set?

Re: Will YOU buy the new MSG set?