Don't ask me why

Anything about Elvis
More than 100 Million visitors can't be wrong

Moderators: Moderator5, Moderator3, FECC-Moderator, Site Mechanic



Topic author
Chucky99
Posts: 898
Registered for: 9 years 1 month
Location: Romania
Has thanked: 119 times
Been thanked: 436 times
Age: 42

Don't ask me why

Post by Chucky99 »

Hello everybody
I realy enjoy this wonderful ballad recorded by Elvis in 1958, from the King Creole LP. I like everything in the song, the Elvis young voice, the orchestration. I think it might be the greatest Elvis ballad from 1958.What do you guys think of this tune?



User avatar

KHoots
Posts: 7560
Registered for: 20 years 11 months
Location: Michigan, USA
Has thanked: 44 times
Been thanked: 171 times

Re: Don't ask me why

Post by KHoots »

Not a bad offering from Elvis, but for my money, the best ballad on the soundtrack is "As Long As I Have You." Very simple and a little corny, but I always liked that song. As for 1958 ballads, I'd have to go with "Don't" over anything else.

Interesting topic, though, as I haven't heard that song in a long time. Thanks for posting!



User avatar

MikeFromHolland
Posts: 7583
Registered for: 12 years
Has thanked: 2479 times
Been thanked: 6844 times

Re: Don't ask me why

Post by MikeFromHolland »

.

Nice song indeed.

..

And what a superb single!

Image

.


Mike

------
lay back,
take it easy
And try a smile...

.


minkahed
Posts: 8622
Registered for: 20 years 10 months
Location: Roanoke, Virginia
Has thanked: 4010 times
Been thanked: 1668 times

Re: Don't ask me why

Post by minkahed »

MikeFromHolland wrote:.

Nice song indeed.

..

And what a superb single!

Image

.
You got that right !!!

The 50's Elvis ... when it seems to have mattered so much.


Image

I don't care what Ed Van Halen says about me--all's I know is that Howard Stern and Mr. Rogers like me just the way I friendly am! - David Lee Roth

User avatar

colonel snow
Posts: 5710
Registered for: 16 years 11 months
Location: antarctica
Has thanked: 466 times
Been thanked: 3446 times
Age: 100

Re: Don't ask me why

Post by colonel snow »

The original version was recorded on 2 september 1954 by Perry Como for RCA; however it's unreleased.

colonel snow



User avatar

MikeFromHolland
Posts: 7583
Registered for: 12 years
Has thanked: 2479 times
Been thanked: 6844 times

Re: Don't ask me why

Post by MikeFromHolland »

.

Does anyone know this version?


Peter McLean And The Henri Bource All Stars ‎– Hard Headed Woman / Don't Ask Me Why
Label: Planet Records (16) ‎– PX 004
Format: Vinyl, 7", 45 RPM, Single
Country: Australia
Released: Nov 1958

Image

Image

Image

Image

From the Hal Wallis Production, "King Creole", a Paramount Film.

This record is renowned for its incredibly rare picture sleeve. Both songs were featured in the film "King Creole" which, of course, featured Elvis Presley.

Bob Crawford (co-owner of Planet Records) asked the Australian distributors of the film if Planet Records could use an image from the film for the picture sleeve, which featured an image of Elvis Presley. This permission was duly given, and a number of picture sleeves were printed and found their way into stores.

However, soon after its release, the local distributor had serious reservations and concerns about Elvis Presley's manager, 'Colonel' Tom Parker, finding out about the use of Elvis' image on a record NOT featuring Elvis himself. They realized that as soon as he found out they would be subject to serious legal action.

While there is no evidence to suggest that 'Colonel' Tom Parker actually ever found out about this, his fearsome reputation for litigation resulted in all sleeves being "withdrawn". (No-one messed with Tom Parker, who was infamous for using heavy legal action to get his way - and winning).

As initial copies - with the "Elvis" sleeve - had already been distributed to stores it was decided to leave them to sell-out and supply future copies without the offending sleeve.
As such, this record - in its picture sleeve - is now amongst the rarest Presley-related records in the world. The last time a copy of this came up for sale it fetched several thousand US dollars. The exact number of copies with sleeves is unknown, but only a few appear to have survived the years.

All subsequent copies of this record came in the standard, generic, green Planet Records die-cut paper sleeve.

Both tracks form this record were issued as 1-sided square cardboard picture discs by Prestodisc as follows:

Peter McLean With The Henri Bource All Stars - Hard Headed Woman
Image

Peter McLean With The Henri Bource All Stars - Don't Ask Me Why
Image
Source: https://www.discogs.com/Peter-McLean-And-The-Henri-Bource-All-Stars-Hard-Headed-Woman-Dont-Ask-Me-Why/release/4000892

.


Mike

------
lay back,
take it easy
And try a smile...

.

User avatar

MikeFromHolland
Posts: 7583
Registered for: 12 years
Has thanked: 2479 times
Been thanked: 6844 times

Re: Don't ask me why

Post by MikeFromHolland »

colonel snow wrote:The original version was recorded on 2 september 1954 by Perry Como for RCA; however it's unreleased.

colonel snow

Is the song with the same name by Jo Stafford another song?

This is from Billboard March 19, 1949:
1949 03 19 Dont ask me why - Jo Stafford.png
It might be the Stolz, Young composition though. Like the Tony Martin version from 1954 was. Can't find any more information.


Released in January 1954:
Image


Sources: https://books.google.nl/books?id=Hw4EAAAAMBAJ&pg=PT42&lpg=PT42&dq=perry+como+don't+ask+me+why&source=bl&ots=Rii9BzwOkM&sig=ZZdt-nK2UrCg7DjLJ47FKU566Wk&hl=nl&sa=X&ved=0ahUKEwiu0Nm0i5TPAhXrAJoKHRm-DqAQ6AEILDAB#v=onepage&q=perry%20como%20don't%20ask%20me%20why&f=false
and
https://books.google.nl/books?id=sh4EAAAAMBAJ&pg=PA22&lpg=PA22&dq=jo+stafford+don't+ask+me+why&source=bl&ots=va9G3_avGX&sig=PLHPFh51qA7L9tXC9ztaveCJXno&hl=nl&sa=X&ved=0ahUKEwi4kYzXi5TPAhUpYZoKHaZ-CZ4Q6AEIKjAB#v=onepage&q=jo%20stafford%20don't%20ask%20me%20why&f=false
.
You do not have the required permissions to view the files attached to this post.


Mike

------
lay back,
take it easy
And try a smile...

.

User avatar

colonel snow
Posts: 5710
Registered for: 16 years 11 months
Location: antarctica
Has thanked: 466 times
Been thanked: 3446 times
Age: 100

Re: Don't ask me why

Post by colonel snow »

It's the same song written by Wise-Weisman.

more information here:

http://kokomo.ca/early_years/dont_ask_me_why.htm

colonel snow



User avatar

MikeFromHolland
Posts: 7583
Registered for: 12 years
Has thanked: 2479 times
Been thanked: 6844 times

Re: Don't ask me why

Post by MikeFromHolland »

colonel snow wrote:It's the same song written by Wise-Weisman.

more information here:

http://kokomo.ca/early_years/dont_ask_me_why.htm

colonel snow
Thank you.

I'm not questioning Perry Como's version. My question concerned the Jo Stafford version. Do you have more info about that one?

.


Mike

------
lay back,
take it easy
And try a smile...

.


Topic author
Chucky99
Posts: 898
Registered for: 9 years 1 month
Location: Romania
Has thanked: 119 times
Been thanked: 436 times
Age: 42

Re: Don't ask me why

Post by Chucky99 »

KHoots wrote:Not a bad offering from Elvis, but for my money, the best ballad on the soundtrack is "As Long As I Have You." Very simple and a little corny, but I always liked that song. As for 1958 ballads, I'd have to go with "Don't" over anything else.

Interesting topic, though, as I haven't heard that song in a long time. Thanks for posting!

I think Don't (which is a classic indeed) was recorded in 1957...




Juan Luis

Re: Don't ask me why

Post by Juan Luis »

My favorite ballad when I first heard the "King Creole" album as a kid. I now prefer "As Long As I have You", especially the piano solo version. "Young Dreams" is another pretty one.



User avatar

colonel snow
Posts: 5710
Registered for: 16 years 11 months
Location: antarctica
Has thanked: 466 times
Been thanked: 3446 times
Age: 100

Re: Don't ask me why

Post by colonel snow »

I've not found any information about Don't ask me why by Jo Stafford; I came a cross live version on Youtube by Marlene Dietricht but that's another song.

colonel snow



User avatar

CONFEDERATELVIS
Posts: 769
Registered for: 19 years 11 months
Has thanked: 277 times
Been thanked: 219 times

Re: Don't ask me why

Post by CONFEDERATELVIS »

I quite like "Young Dreams" for the ballad for the film, in general I personally think "I need you so" for the ballad of the 50s


You're a doctor too so your three doctors - Basil Fawlty

User avatar

Fabbe
Posts: 1882
Registered for: 20 years 11 months
Has thanked: 1201 times
Been thanked: 718 times

Re: Don't ask me why

Post by Fabbe »

Love the song and the soundtrack - Elvis at his best


Inviato dal mio iPhone utilizzando Tapatalk


"An artist like Elvis is actually pretending, when he’s home, to be normal. And when he goes out on stage at night is who he actually is." — Bruce Springsteen


r&b

Re: Don't ask me why

Post by r&b »

Great song, and B side. A song that should be better known. Elvis movie songs in the 50's for the most part were all very good. Dunno what happened to the writers after 1960. I guess the movie plots had something to do with it.



User avatar

jurasic1968
Posts: 12414
Registered for: 11 years 7 months
Has thanked: 13556 times
Been thanked: 2599 times

Re: Don't ask me why

Post by jurasic1968 »

And because The Colonel didn't want Leiber and Stoller again.




Davelee
Banned -- Same user as "mysterytrainrideson"
Banned -- Same user as "mysterytrainrideson"
Posts: 3027
Registered for: 8 years 10 months
Has thanked: 887 times
Been thanked: 622 times

Re: Don't ask me why

Post by Davelee »

Good song! The King Creole album ticks all the right boxes. The weak song on the album, for me, is "Young Dreams". I'm not including "Steadfast, Loyal and True" because it wasn't really intended as a song as such but just a sequence for the movie.



User avatar

elvis-fan
Posts: 16745
Registered for: 20 years 11 months
Location: Canada
Has thanked: 3975 times
Been thanked: 5509 times
Age: 89

Re: Don't ask me why

Post by elvis-fan »

A beautiful recording from our man... at a time when he could do no wrong.

The King Creole soundtrack in its entirety (save Steadfast...) is an absolute gem. No other soundtrack comes close...


Image




Davelee
Banned -- Same user as "mysterytrainrideson"
Banned -- Same user as "mysterytrainrideson"
Posts: 3027
Registered for: 8 years 10 months
Has thanked: 887 times
Been thanked: 622 times

Re: Don't ask me why

Post by Davelee »

r&b wrote:Great song, and B side. A song that should be better known. Elvis movie songs in the 50's for the most part were all very good. Dunno what happened to the writers after 1960. I guess the movie plots had something to do with it.
Imagine Leiber and Stoller being given the script "Kissin' Cousins" and asked if they could write some songs...one look at that script would be enough to put them off. Besides, with the old dutchman sticking his nose where it didn't belong wouldn't have bothered the songwriters one iota, they were good enough writers and confident to go elsewhere they didn't need Elvis anymore though Elvis probably needed them - Elvis should have told the mad dutchman to stick his big fat cigar up his backside.



User avatar

TheKingisthething
Posts: 535
Registered for: 9 years 11 months
Has thanked: 27 times
Been thanked: 193 times

Re: Don't ask me why

Post by TheKingisthething »

CONFEDERATELVIS wrote:I quite like "Young Dreams" for the ballad for the film, in general I personally think "I need you so" for the ballad of the 50s
Best ballads of the fifties:

Blue Moon
Any Way You Want Me
Is It So Strange
Don't




r&b

Re: Don't ask me why

Post by r&b »

Davelee wrote:
r&b wrote:Great song, and B side. A song that should be better known. Elvis movie songs in the 50's for the most part were all very good. Dunno what happened to the writers after 1960. I guess the movie plots had something to do with it.
Imagine Leiber and Stoller being given the script "Kissin' Cousins" and asked if they could write some songs...one look at that script would be enough to put them off. Besides, with the old dutchman sticking his nose where it didn't belong wouldn't have bothered the songwriters one iota, they were good enough writers and confident to go elsewhere they didn't need Elvis anymore though Elvis probably needed them - Elvis should have told the mad dutchman to stick his big fat cigar up his backside.
Didnt someone contact them (the Col?) for writing songs for Elvis' first post army move (GI Blues)? When they heard the demands didnt Jerry tell the Col to go blank himself? I dont know if this is really true, but I thought I read it somewhere.




Davelee
Banned -- Same user as "mysterytrainrideson"
Banned -- Same user as "mysterytrainrideson"
Posts: 3027
Registered for: 8 years 10 months
Has thanked: 887 times
Been thanked: 622 times

Re: Don't ask me why

Post by Davelee »

r&b wrote:
Davelee wrote:
r&b wrote:Great song, and B side. A song that should be better known. Elvis movie songs in the 50's for the most part were all very good. Dunno what happened to the writers after 1960. I guess the movie plots had something to do with it.
Imagine Leiber and Stoller being given the script "Kissin' Cousins" and asked if they could write some songs...one look at that script would be enough to put them off. Besides, with the old dutchman sticking his nose where it didn't belong wouldn't have bothered the songwriters one iota, they were good enough writers and confident to go elsewhere they didn't need Elvis anymore though Elvis probably needed them - Elvis should have told the mad dutchman to stick his big fat cigar up his backside.
Didnt someone contact them (the Col?) for writing songs for Elvis' first post army move (GI Blues)? When they heard the demands didnt Jerry tell the Col to go blank himself? I dont know if this is really true, but I thought I read it somewhere.
It sounds like the story before Elvis entered the army. Apparently, the Col sent them a contract to sign but the contract didn't specifically say what it was for, so Jerry or Mike phoned the Col and asked "Whats the contract for?" the Col said "you will know soon enough" one of them said "i'll get back to you". The two then discussed the situation, phoned the Col back and said, "we've had i chat about it and we both agreed that you should go and f@#k yourself", with that the phone went down. Thats the way i've read it.




r&b

Re: Don't ask me why

Post by r&b »

Davelee wrote:
r&b wrote:
Davelee wrote:
r&b wrote:Great song, and B side. A song that should be better known. Elvis movie songs in the 50's for the most part were all very good. Dunno what happened to the writers after 1960. I guess the movie plots had something to do with it.
Imagine Leiber and Stoller being given the script "Kissin' Cousins" and asked if they could write some songs...one look at that script would be enough to put them off. Besides, with the old dutchman sticking his nose where it didn't belong wouldn't have bothered the songwriters one iota, they were good enough writers and confident to go elsewhere they didn't need Elvis anymore though Elvis probably needed them - Elvis should have told the mad dutchman to stick his big fat cigar up his backside.
Didnt someone contact them (the Col?) for writing songs for Elvis' first post army move (GI Blues)? When they heard the demands didnt Jerry tell the Col to go blank himself? I dont know if this is really true, but I thought I read it somewhere.
It sounds like the story before Elvis entered the army. Apparently, the Col sent them a contract to sign but the contract didn't specifically say what it was for, so Jerry or Mike phoned the Col and asked "Whats the contract for?" the Col said "you will know soon enough" one of them said "i'll get back to you". The two then discussed the situation, phoned the Col back and said, "we've had i chat about it and we both agreed that you should go and f@#k yourself", with that the phone went down. Thats the way i've read it.
Ok, yeah, it was before GI Blues



User avatar

MikeFromHolland
Posts: 7583
Registered for: 12 years
Has thanked: 2479 times
Been thanked: 6844 times

Re: Don't ask me why

Post by MikeFromHolland »

.

A German version from 1959:

..

.


Mike

------
lay back,
take it easy
And try a smile...

.

User avatar

jeanno
Posts: 3697
Registered for: 20 years 4 months
Location: Murcia (España)
Has thanked: 564 times
Been thanked: 848 times

Re: Don't ask me why

Post by jeanno »

Best ballads from the 50s
3. Anyway you want me
2. Don't
1. Blue moon

Best ballad from 1954 to 1977
3. Anyway you want me
2. Don't
1. Blue moon