Post here all polls related to Elvis Albums/Songs Etc.

The song Mister songman is

Excellent
5
15%
Very Good
6
18%
Good
9
26%
Average
7
21%
Bad
3
9%
Boring
4
12%
 
Total votes : 34

Mister songman

Thu Jun 04, 2009 1:56 pm

Hello

Your opinion of this song :?:

Re: Mister songman

Thu Jun 04, 2009 1:59 pm

very good i think

Re: Mister songman

Thu Jun 04, 2009 2:38 pm

I have always liked the song for personal reasons. Especially that tag line, "Take away the night, sing away my hurt, Mr. Songman."

Not an Elvis classic by any means, but very pleasant to these ears.

Re: Mister songman

Thu Jun 04, 2009 6:56 pm

Rob wrote:I have always liked the song for personal reasons. Especially that tag line, "Take away the night, sing away my hurt, Mr. Songman."

Not an Elvis classic by any means, but very pleasant to these ears.



I agree, Rob. It's not what one would term a 'classic' Elvis song but it is one of my favorites. I love the mix on the 70s box set of this song.

Re: Mister songman

Thu Jun 04, 2009 6:58 pm

Bad

Re: Mister songman

Thu Jun 04, 2009 7:56 pm

I´ve never liked that song, one of his worst from the 70:s.
Still don´t understand why it was chosen as the flip side to T.R.O.U.B.L.E.

So I voted "Bad"

All my humble opinion, of course!

Lennart

Re: Mister songman

Fri Jun 05, 2009 1:45 pm

A good performance of a boring song in my opinion. Boring is what I voted!

//Björn

Re: Mister songman

Fri Jun 05, 2009 1:51 pm

Rob wrote:I have always liked the song for personal reasons.


But a person's like or dislike of a song is always based on 'personal reasons' isn't it ?

I guess you mean the song has some 'special' meaning for you..............

Re: Mister songman

Fri Jun 05, 2009 11:24 pm

tcb4 wrote:Hello

Your opinion of this song :?:

In a career filled with peaks, Elvis was really peaking when he cut the master of "Mr. Songman."

"Take away the knives, sing away my skirt, Mr. Sooongmaaaan."

Re: Mister songman

Sat Jun 06, 2009 2:51 am

At best it's fair to middlin.' I think it's the weakest track from the December '73 Stax sessions. Somebody shoulda said "Elvis, forget about this one and do another Chuck Berry tune!"

Re: Mister songman

Sat Jun 06, 2009 3:16 am

Pete Dube wrote:At best it's fair to middlin.' I think it's the weakest track from the December '73 Stax sessions. Somebody shoulda said "Elvis, forget about this one and do another Chuck Berry tune!"

Or if anything, hunt down some more Shirl Milete gold.

Re: Mister songman

Sat Jun 06, 2009 3:24 am

drjohncarpenter wrote:In a career filled with peaks, Elvis was really peaking when he cut the master of "Mr. Songman."

"Take away the knives, sing away my skirt, Mr. Sooongmaaaan."

Have you been experimenting in the medicine cabinet again?

Re: Mister songman

Sat Jun 06, 2009 1:12 pm

I like it.

Re: Mister songman

Sat Jun 06, 2009 2:20 pm

It's an ok album cut. Not bad, not great. Some of the harmonies are nice, but nothing I play over and over.

Re: Mister songman

Wed Jun 10, 2009 5:42 pm

midnightx wrote:
Pete Dube wrote:At best it's fair to middlin.' I think it's the weakest track from the December '73 Stax sessions. Somebody shoulda said "Elvis, forget about this one and do another Chuck Berry tune!"

Or if anything, hunt down some more Shirl Milete gold.


Only if Shirl had another "It's Your Baby, You Rock It" lying around.

Re: Mister songman

Fri Jun 12, 2009 7:49 am

I don't think it's terrible. It's kind of a mediocre country singalong type song. The verse lyric would benefit from being a little less pretentious. Elvis' performance is committed but careful. I see this song as kind of an exercise more than as an artistic statement.

Lennart- If you can't bury a pedestrian track on a B-side where can you put it. Elvis, for most of his career, was unique in even paying attention to B-sides. Phil Spector was so focused on A-sides that he would make the B-sides deliberately unlistenable in order to keep attention on the A. This was especially so after "Unchained Melody" a song he considered a toss off, topped "Hung on You."

Re: Mister songman

Fri Jun 12, 2009 8:06 am

likethebike wrote:I don't think it's terrible. It's kind of a mediocre country singalong type song. The verse lyric would benefit from being a little less pretentious. Elvis' performance is committed but careful. I see this song as kind of an exercise more than as an artistic statement.

Sadly, this scenario played out way too often for an artist of Elvis' talents.

Re: Mister songman

Fri Jun 12, 2009 8:15 am

It's just that Elvis was musical woodshedder and sometimes you had to go through this stuff to reach the classics. We had to go through "I Love You Because" and "Harbor Lights" (sorry Cryo) to get to "That's All Right Mama." The same could be said of this song and "Promised Land."

Re: Mister songman

Fri Jun 12, 2009 8:20 am

likethebike wrote:It's just that Elvis was musical woodshedder and sometimes you had to go through this stuff to reach the classics. We had to go through "I Love You Because" and "Harbor Lights" (sorry Cryo) to get to "That's All Right Mama." The same could be said of this song and "Promised Land."

There was a lot more, uh, woodshedding in the 1970s, with very little payback when compared to the 1950s.

Re: Mister songman

Fri Jun 12, 2009 5:10 pm

Pleasant enough song, well performed. I like it a lot, but can see why others would despise it. Not a classic of course.

I voted good.

Re: Mister songman

Fri Jun 12, 2009 5:42 pm

Average for me. Nothing special.

Re: Mister songman

Sat Jun 13, 2009 10:57 am

I'd rather listen to "Harbor Lights" (which is an outtake) than to "Mister Songman". Can't say the same for "I Love You Because" though...yuck.

Re: Mister songman

Sat Jun 13, 2009 2:38 pm

Lennart- If you can't bury a pedestrian track on a B-side where can you put it. Elvis, for most of his career, was unique in even paying attention to B-sides. Phil Spector was so focused on A-sides that he would make the B-sides deliberately unlistenable in order to keep attention on the A. This was especially so after "Unchained Melody" a song he considered a toss off, topped "Hung on You."[/quote]

Well, my opinion is that he should never recorded the song in the first place.
Since he did record it, it should not been released and if Elvis/Felton/RCA STILL would have it relaesed, it was quite enough to have it released on the "Promised Land" LP.

The B-side to T.R.O.U.B.L.E should have been "Pieces of my life" instead.
"Bringing it back" wasn´t that all great A-side but the B-side was really good.

Lennart

Re: Mister songman

Thu Jun 18, 2009 6:52 am

likethebike wrote:It's just that Elvis was musical woodshedder and sometimes you had to go through this stuff to reach the classics. We had to go through "I Love You Because" and "Harbor Lights" (sorry Cryo) to get to "That's All Right Mama." The same could be said of this song and "Promised Land."


GRRRRGGGH!!!!!

*shakes fist in LTB's direction*

:wink:

I understand what you're saying, LTB, but it just comes down to personal taste.

I don't personally find "Mr Songman" earth-shattering, but some, perhaps most, wouldn't agree with all my choices, either.

Heck, outside of the EP World, Elvis isn't even admired very much as an artist, these days. Everyone has their own interests and likes/dislikes.

Re: Mister songman

Fri Jun 19, 2009 5:01 am

drjohncarpenter wrote:
likethebike wrote:It's just that Elvis was musical woodshedder and sometimes you had to go through this stuff to reach the classics. We had to go through "I Love You Because" and "Harbor Lights" (sorry Cryo) to get to "That's All Right Mama." The same could be said of this song and "Promised Land."

There was a lot more, uh, woodshedding in the 1970s, with very little payback when compared to the 1950s.


What're you gonna do? Sometimes you're more on your game than other times.