Sat Nov 10, 2012 7:57 am
poormadpeter wrote:it gets worse.
Sat Nov 10, 2012 8:42 am
poormadpeter wrote:The fans who are interested in this are the same ones that pay out for FTDs every quarter. And we know those figures are a mere 5000 at most.
Sat Nov 10, 2012 9:00 am
Sat Nov 10, 2012 9:30 am
Sat Nov 10, 2012 9:47 am
Sat Nov 10, 2012 10:02 am
TJ wrote:Brian, it's not only US sales that matter. There's a big Elvis market outside the US and that would be considered. But, you are very optimistic if you believe that one million sales are likely for an Elvis On Tour project.
Sat Nov 10, 2012 10:45 am
Sat Nov 10, 2012 1:47 pm
Sat Nov 10, 2012 7:25 pm
brian wrote:I got an idea if you want Elvis On Tour released on DVD with bonus features and interviews like TTWII Special edition.
You have to ask the question how many Elvis fans are there in the United States that would be interested in buying an Elvis on Tour special edition DVD?
If the answer is 1 million fans you may be able to sell the idea to Time Warner.
You must show Time Warner that a lot of Elvis fans would buy it not just the limited number of die hards on internet forums.
People are always saying that Elvis is the most popular entertainer and that he has the most fans out of anyone.
If you want it done then show Time Warner how many Elvis fans there are.
They'd put it out if EOT would make money for them.
Do it now while the TCB band members, Jerry Schilling and Joe Esposito are still alive to provide commentary.
Sat Nov 10, 2012 8:18 pm
SuspiciousMind wrote:brian wrote:I got an idea if you want Elvis On Tour released on DVD with bonus features and interviews like TTWII Special edition.
You have to ask the question how many Elvis fans are there in the United States that would be interested in buying an Elvis on Tour special edition DVD?
If the answer is 1 million fans you may be able to sell the idea to Time Warner.
You must show Time Warner that a lot of Elvis fans would buy it not just the limited number of die hards on internet forums.
People are always saying that Elvis is the most popular entertainer and that he has the most fans out of anyone.
If you want it done then show Time Warner how many Elvis fans there are.
They'd put it out if EOT would make money for them.
Do it now while the TCB band members, Jerry Schilling and Joe Esposito are still alive to provide commentary.
Great idea! But it needs to be a worldwide strategic marketing plan. Not just for the United States. Time-Warner needs to know who is and how many are visiting Graceland, young and old, buying Elvis dvds and cds on a demographic level. It also needs to be when the economy is sturdy enough to move units, otherwise it will be a failure. TW could also consider making a bran new EOT type of film where all new footage is used and make it a theatrical release with it going to dvd a few months later. That way, they make back the money they spent to restore the footage and promotion costs just off of ticket sales. They would then make a profit off of dvd sales. That's how Michael Jackson's estate made up so much debt that he owed, was by putting This Is It in theaters and gaining back big revenue off of ticket sales then dvd sales.
Sat Nov 10, 2012 8:28 pm
poormadpeter wrote:SuspiciousMind wrote:brian wrote:I got an idea if you want Elvis On Tour released on DVD with bonus features and interviews like TTWII Special edition.
You have to ask the question how many Elvis fans are there in the United States that would be interested in buying an Elvis on Tour special edition DVD?
If the answer is 1 million fans you may be able to sell the idea to Time Warner.
You must show Time Warner that a lot of Elvis fans would buy it not just the limited number of die hards on internet forums.
People are always saying that Elvis is the most popular entertainer and that he has the most fans out of anyone.
If you want it done then show Time Warner how many Elvis fans there are.
They'd put it out if EOT would make money for them.
Do it now while the TCB band members, Jerry Schilling and Joe Esposito are still alive to provide commentary.
Great idea! But it needs to be a worldwide strategic marketing plan. Not just for the United States. Time-Warner needs to know who is and how many are visiting Graceland, young and old, buying Elvis dvds and cds on a demographic level. It also needs to be when the economy is sturdy enough to move units, otherwise it will be a failure. TW could also consider making a bran new EOT type of film where all new footage is used and make it a theatrical release with it going to dvd a few months later. That way, they make back the money they spent to restore the footage and promotion costs just off of ticket sales. They would then make a profit off of dvd sales. That's how Michael Jackson's estate made up so much debt that he owed, was by putting This Is It in theaters and gaining back big revenue off of ticket sales then dvd sales.
We should make sure that this argument doesn't go down route of "This Is It made money so EOT will too". This Is It was a hit not just because of MJ fans going to see it or buying it, but because the artist in question had died a few months earlier and therefore the general population wanted a piece of the action or, at worst, they had a morbid curiosity of whether MJ would have pulled off those concerts had he not died. It's no different to the surge in LP sales when Elvis died.
We also need to remember that the people going through Graceland may very well no be fans willing to shell out on a DVD. YMWTBB did not sell hundreds of thousands of copies, despite hundreds of thousands of people going through Graceland. And while to us that package only had 30 minutes of unreleased material, to all but the 5000 fans who buy FTDs, most of the outtakes would have been new too.
But yes, if someone could persuade Warner that X amount of people would buy the EOT footage then it would get released. The problem here is that this can't be done. A petition online would garner perhaps a couple of thousand names. You can't point to recent Elvis DVDs selling huge numbers unless you go back 8 years to the 68 special and the aloha sets - but, again, these were historically important shows and EOT is not. What's more, that was nearly a decade ago. No recent Elvis release has sold in huge quantities.
LTB, although I don't agree with everything he says, has clearly pointed out that better, more respected films are being released only through burn on demand dvds - including classic musicals that people have lobbied to get on DVD for years, such as Good News, the Mario Lanza films, Tom Thumb, Rhapsody In Blue, and Meet Me In las Vegas - the last two of which are full of cameos so that they would appeal to collectors of any number of stars.
I don;t think the copyright laws are an issue here - they would never be made so that material from 1940 years ago could be bought for a song. They are a problem with early film though and in the way that LTB describes. The material is under copyright but the studio can't make money from it as the market is too small, and the grey market labels can't put it out either, and so it rots. The issue for EOT is principally the same, but to hope or suggest that laws with cut 50 years of copyright is just folly, sadly.
Sat Nov 10, 2012 8:42 pm
SuspiciousMind wrote:poormadpeter wrote:SuspiciousMind wrote:brian wrote:I got an idea if you want Elvis On Tour released on DVD with bonus features and interviews like TTWII Special edition.
You have to ask the question how many Elvis fans are there in the United States that would be interested in buying an Elvis on Tour special edition DVD?
If the answer is 1 million fans you may be able to sell the idea to Time Warner.
You must show Time Warner that a lot of Elvis fans would buy it not just the limited number of die hards on internet forums.
People are always saying that Elvis is the most popular entertainer and that he has the most fans out of anyone.
If you want it done then show Time Warner how many Elvis fans there are.
They'd put it out if EOT would make money for them.
Do it now while the TCB band members, Jerry Schilling and Joe Esposito are still alive to provide commentary.
Great idea! But it needs to be a worldwide strategic marketing plan. Not just for the United States. Time-Warner needs to know who is and how many are visiting Graceland, young and old, buying Elvis dvds and cds on a demographic level. It also needs to be when the economy is sturdy enough to move units, otherwise it will be a failure. TW could also consider making a bran new EOT type of film where all new footage is used and make it a theatrical release with it going to dvd a few months later. That way, they make back the money they spent to restore the footage and promotion costs just off of ticket sales. They would then make a profit off of dvd sales. That's how Michael Jackson's estate made up so much debt that he owed, was by putting This Is It in theaters and gaining back big revenue off of ticket sales then dvd sales.
We should make sure that this argument doesn't go down route of "This Is It made money so EOT will too". This Is It was a hit not just because of MJ fans going to see it or buying it, but because the artist in question had died a few months earlier and therefore the general population wanted a piece of the action or, at worst, they had a morbid curiosity of whether MJ would have pulled off those concerts had he not died. It's no different to the surge in LP sales when Elvis died.
We also need to remember that the people going through Graceland may very well no be fans willing to shell out on a DVD. YMWTBB did not sell hundreds of thousands of copies, despite hundreds of thousands of people going through Graceland. And while to us that package only had 30 minutes of unreleased material, to all but the 5000 fans who buy FTDs, most of the outtakes would have been new too.
But yes, if someone could persuade Warner that X amount of people would buy the EOT footage then it would get released. The problem here is that this can't be done. A petition online would garner perhaps a couple of thousand names. You can't point to recent Elvis DVDs selling huge numbers unless you go back 8 years to the 68 special and the aloha sets - but, again, these were historically important shows and EOT is not. What's more, that was nearly a decade ago. No recent Elvis release has sold in huge quantities.
LTB, although I don't agree with everything he says, has clearly pointed out that better, more respected films are being released only through burn on demand dvds - including classic musicals that people have lobbied to get on DVD for years, such as Good News, the Mario Lanza films, Tom Thumb, Rhapsody In Blue, and Meet Me In las Vegas - the last two of which are full of cameos so that they would appeal to collectors of any number of stars.
I don;t think the copyright laws are an issue here - they would never be made so that material from 1940 years ago could be bought for a song. They are a problem with early film though and in the way that LTB describes. The material is under copyright but the studio can't make money from it as the market is too small, and the grey market labels can't put it out either, and so it rots. The issue for EOT is principally the same, but to hope or suggest that laws with cut 50 years of copyright is just folly, sadly.
You're missing the whole point. This Is It was still a theatrical release first and for a main purpose. To gain revenue off of mass ticket sales and to take advantage of a situation, his death. The same would be for "newly discovered concert footage" of Elvis still physically healthy and rocking before the end began. .
Sat Nov 10, 2012 9:06 pm
Sat Nov 10, 2012 9:09 pm
brian wrote:
Did you not read PoormadPeter's post about being literally the only person at a screening for the That's the way it is special edition?
Sat Nov 10, 2012 9:14 pm
poormadpeter wrote:I completely believe that, had TTWII SE been a huge financial success, that we would have had a similar EOT venture by now. But it wasn't. And many will blame the fact that it was shown on TCM before it went to video, but we buy DVDs of TV series and programmes that have just been shown on a very regular basis. The TCM showing was the biggest advert the DVD could have had. And, no doubt, every hardcore fan bought that DVD release, and still it wasn't deemed a big enough success to risk money on the next venture.
Sat Nov 10, 2012 9:23 pm
SuspiciousMind wrote:brian wrote:
Did you not read PoormadPeter's post about being literally the only person at a screening for the That's the way it is special edition?
I did read that. But did he also read where I stated back pages ago that when EOT was released to American theaters in 2010 that it was a major success? Sold out many US theaters for the one night it played..
Sat Nov 10, 2012 10:34 pm
SuspiciousMind wrote:brian wrote:
Did you not read PoormadPeter's post about being literally the only person at a screening for the That's the way it is special edition?
I did read that. But did he also read where I stated back pages ago that when EOT was released to American theaters in 2010 that it was a major success? Sold out many US theaters for the one night it played. I also pointed out too that TTWII Special Edition came out back in 2001, before a new crop of Elvis fans came along. Elvis' sales prior to 2002 were dismal at best. Since then, he's had several top 10 to top 40 albums. 30 Number One Hits (#1), Second To None (#3), Elvis By The Presleys (#15), Viva Elvis (top 40), Christmas Duets (Top 20), An Afternoon In The Garden (#28). If That's The Way It Is had come out today instead of 2001, it would have charted and pretty high at that. All one has to do is look at the recent success of The Elvis Experience in Brazil and you will see (A) that Elvis is still a major draw and has unlimited appeal fan following and (B) can still draw in thousands to see him perform on a video screen. If he can do that in an arena with footage already available on dvd, then he should be able to pack them into a smaller theater for a NEW feature presentation.
Sat Nov 10, 2012 10:44 pm
How many artists do you know that sell huge numbers on a yearly basis? Better yet, how many of them are non living? I'll wait for your answer.poormadpeter wrote:SuspiciousMind wrote:brian wrote:
Did you not read PoormadPeter's post about being literally the only person at a screening for the That's the way it is special edition?
I did read that. But did he also read where I stated back pages ago that when EOT was released to American theaters in 2010 that it was a major success? Sold out many US theaters for the one night it played. I also pointed out too that TTWII Special Edition came out back in 2001, before a new crop of Elvis fans came along. Elvis' sales prior to 2002 were dismal at best. Since then, he's had several top 10 to top 40 albums. 30 Number One Hits (#1), Second To None (#3), Elvis By The Presleys (#15), Viva Elvis (top 40), Christmas Duets (Top 20), An Afternoon In The Garden (#28). If That's The Way It Is had come out today instead of 2001, it would have charted and pretty high at that. All one has to do is look at the recent success of The Elvis Experience in Brazil and you will see (A) that Elvis is still a major draw and has unlimited appeal fan following and (B) can still draw in thousands to see him perform on a video screen. If he can do that in an arena with footage already available on dvd, then he should be able to pack them into a smaller theater for a NEW feature presentation.
Yes, it sold out many US cinemas on the ONE NIGHT it played - because it only played for ONE NIGHT. had it played for seven nights, it would simply have meant that the audience of the one night would have been spread over seven different ones.
And to suggest that fans didn't buy TTWII because this or that wasn't included on the DVD is poppyc*ck. There was enough new material in the recut film, both from rehearsals and live performances, to make every Elvis fan go out and buy that DVD - and no doubt they did. I have yet to hear one person on this board say that they did not buy the TTWII SE because extra footage was not included. Not one. Hell, most fans get excited at the prospect of one unreleased take on a CD, let alone new video footage. And when that unseen footage WAS included on the double disc of TTWII, fans moaned because it wasn't in good enough quality.
And the idea that a sellout concert in Brazil is an indication of DVD sales is ridiculous. Again, one fan goes there with his entire family. That's four tickets sold for every fan who might buy a DVD. What's more, seeing the concert is an event (I don't see the attraction personally, but that's neither here nor there). Not everyone who went to the olympics is a sports fan. They went because it was an event.
And Brian, it's not a case of trying to persuade me that this should be released. I would love to see it released, in the same way that I would love to see every film sitting in the vaults released. BUT, we can not look at this objectively if we look at it as a fan. We have to step back and look at the cold hard facts. And the facts are that Warner financed the special edition of TTWII and it basically flopped.
What's more, Elvis CDs are not selling in huge numbers. On one hand there is the argument on these boards that reaching the top of the charts these days means practically nothing because you don't have to sell many copies any more, but then when Elvis hits the charts with a #28 album we deem this a huge success and an indication that huge numbers of his CDs are being shifted. You can't have it both ways.
Sat Nov 10, 2012 10:50 pm
Sat Nov 10, 2012 11:09 pm
likethebike wrote:"Elvis attracts a special kind of fan. Yip." Again more fan and fellow poster bashing. Really???
Sat Nov 10, 2012 11:27 pm
Sat Nov 10, 2012 11:37 pm
Sat Nov 10, 2012 11:50 pm
Sun Nov 11, 2012 12:08 am
jurasic1968 wrote:EPE is obligated to do a multiple DVD Deluxe edition Elvis on Tour. I wonder how much money will cost for the 4 concerts filmed to be released in their entirety? I don't think too much. I am not very excited about the rehearsals (Elvis seems bored and sometimes uninspired in them) but I care very much for the very exciting 4 filmed concerts. So let's move on and made a petition to EPE to begin this project!!
Sun Nov 11, 2012 12:15 am
Scarre wrote:drjohncarpenter wrote:poormadpeter wrote:As has been stated earlier, Aloha and the 68 comeback are legendary events. Elvis On Tour is just a concert film. While the TV specials might be of interest to more casual fans and general rock enthusiasts because of their legendary status, Elvis On Tour would not be.
Reality check. "Elvis On Tour" is a concert documentary that won a MAJOR award, a Golden Globe. It was the first to not only document what he was currently doing but also his breakthrough in the 1950s, incorporating kinescope TV footage from 1956, which gave the film an added historical pedigree.poormadpeter wrote:Reality check. According to TCM, currently 3.6% of all films in their database are currently available on dvd in the USA. While those figures might not be totally accurate (especially as it probably doesn't include short films), it does give an indication of how lucky we are to have the amount of material available to us as Elvis fans - including 100% of Presley's movie output. We could probably count on one hand the amount of film stars who have 100% of their output on DVD:
Not Sinatra,
not Crosby,
not John Wayne,
not Steve McQueen
not even Alfred Hitchcock.
And yet fans feel they are hard-done-by.
As I've said before, unlike the tampered-with, official DVD, any proper representation of the MGM film means a fully-restored version of what was seen in theaters in 1972. Until this happens, fans do not have 100% of Presley's movie output.
Again, it is this version of "Elvis On Tour" that shared the 1972 Golden Globe Best Documentary Film award with "Walls of Fire."
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Walls_of_Fire
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/30th_Golden_Globe_Awards#Best_Documentary_Film
The 30th Golden Globe Award ceremony was held on Sunday, January 28, 1973 at the Century Plaza Hotel in Los Angeles. Presley was at the Las Vegas Hilton, in his suite between shows. He was watching from the bathroom when the news broke that "Elvis On Tour" won, and he came hopping out, excited over the honor.
Imagine what an elite DVD label Criterion would do if they got the chance to release a DVD/BluRay of "Elvis On Tour."
The Criterion Collection
http://www.criterion.com/
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Criterion_Collection
A good point. I also agree with what steve in SC wrote.
Hosted by ElviCities