Fri Sep 21, 2012 9:46 pm
Good Time Charlie wrote:Dan_T wrote:I watched this on TV a couple of nights ago, and my first thought was an article I read some 20 odd
years ago in which Tom said he jammed with Elvis in Hawaii, he said he knew more Chords than Elvis did, watching this shows he was talking crap !
A home recording of Tom and Elvis jamming together in the late 60s would be amazing.
I'd bet they sung all those old R&B numbers.
Fri Sep 21, 2012 11:09 pm
Fri Sep 21, 2012 11:43 pm
Sat Sep 22, 2012 12:52 am
FredAistair wrote:Allowing for the Tom Jones love in, How is this a great version of A Mess of Blues?
True Tom has retained his voice and that is one hell of an achievement.
However Tom sang everthing the same, this included.
Subtlety ,texture, phrasing and tenderness were and are not part of Tom's repertoire.
Sat Sep 22, 2012 1:12 pm
Xaykev wrote:FredAistair wrote:Allowing for the Tom Jones love in, How is this a great version of A Mess of Blues?
True Tom has retained his voice and that is one hell of an achievement.
However Tom sang everthing the same, this included.
Subtlety ,texture, phrasing and tenderness were and are not part of Tom's repertoire.
I must say that I agree with you. He has a strong voice and great range, but like you wrote..phrasing and tenderness not something he does very well.
Sat Sep 22, 2012 9:57 pm
Sat Sep 22, 2012 11:32 pm
Oqi wrote:Xaykev wrote:FredAistair wrote:Allowing for the Tom Jones love in, How is this a great version of A Mess of Blues?
True Tom has retained his voice and that is one hell of an achievement.
However Tom sang everthing the same, this included.
Subtlety ,texture, phrasing and tenderness were and are not part of Tom's repertoire.
I must say that I agree with you. He has a strong voice and great range, but like you wrote..phrasing and tenderness not something he does very well.
Have you heard his 3 last albums at all?
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jOd9pdtn1ik
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3TubV1vKClk
Those albums all got great reviews by critics. I don't think that's oversinging. And that's just example. And saying that Tom is not good in phrasing that's just a joke, a big joke!
Let me quote Big Jim Sullivan who played as a session musician in (one thousand charting singles over his career.)
"I got on well with Tom That's why I'm throwing him over the Niagara Falls. Don't worry Tom Fans it was all put on for the photograph. Still the memories from those days are with me until I die. I think I had more experience of life in the 5 years working with Tom than I did All the rest of my life put together. The problem was none of it was to do with music. I will put it all down in a book one day but I think one of us or even both of us should be dead. Neither of us would like to sue the other but it could end up like that. Tom is a great guy and lives for the road. He has such a disciplined lifestyle and keeps himself very fit. I don't think he has many intellectual pursuance's but he leads a very full life. (Chuckle) I do think that Tom would have been one of the greatest operatic singers that ever lived if he had classical training. I have never heard such a powerful and tuneful voice in my life as a musician. When we rehearsed you could here his voice over the top of the full orchestra. His pitch was total on every note and his feel for time and phrasing was impeccable. I know musicians from all styles had great respect for Tom. I have heard him sing the blues with a voice like Howling Wolf and BB King put together. The man is a total natural and very few people have this kind of talent. I only left Tom because my own way in life was not compatible with the life on the road."
If you heard just the hits by Tom its easy to judge but there is lot more and i would go as far and say his best singing and songs are buried there somewhere in the shadows of his hits.
Sun Sep 30, 2012 3:34 pm
Hosted by ElviCities