Greystoke wrote:brian wrote:Greystoke wrote:I'm just waiting to see Swiss Army Man at the cinema. That's one you asked me about a few days ago, brian. And I've just seen Free State of Jones and Miss Peregrine`s Home for Peculiar Children.
I hope that you will please tell me what you think about them after you've seen them.
The standout of the three is, unquestionably, Swiss Army Man. Which is one of the most bold, daring and original films I've seen all year. The story, ostensibly, is about a man (Paul Dano) who is stranded on an island and has lost so much hope that he's about to commit suicide. But he's distracted by a body that washes up on the beach. Upon inspection, the corpse (Daniel Radcliffe) is full of wind and flatulating so much that he's able to ride it like a jet ski off the island.
Upon arriving on what seems to be the mainland, the corpse reveals all sorts of surprising uses -- it fills up with water after rainfall and spews like a running tap. It can fire objects from its mouth, can be used to break wood and gets an erection that works as navigational instrument. So far so utterly bizarre, but there's a rich and revealing subtext here that may be obvious in some ways, but is profound and stark in the way mental and emotional health is discussed. But I think that's best left discovered by watching. Otherwise, this is a striking movie that's superbly crafted and brilliantly acted.
Free State of Jones is also well acted, and that's the film's saving grace. The story, about Newton Knight, has been depicted on screen before, but this is a visceral and immediately involving movie that drops the ball with regards to its narrative structure and characterisation. Knight, played by Matthew McConaughey, is akin to Robin Hood in the way he assembles a band of weary and disenfranchised slaves and deserters to fight alone against an oppressive Confederate government.
McConaughey is terrific, but the narrative is fractured by jumping forward sixty years to a court case involving his descendant grandson, and struggles to keep real focus on the many characters and events that are depicted. Especially in the film's final act, which takes place after the Civil War. Characters are sketchy, at times cliched, such as Knight's wife, who isn't identified as his wife until late in the movie, and a villainous plantation owner. Who is just a villainous plantation owner.
The standout performers, next to McConaughey, are Mahershala Ali, who plays Moses, a slave Knight becomes close friends with. And the wonderful Gugu Mbatha-Raw, a house slave whom he falls for. But I wanted much more from their characters, both in the writing and time spent in their company. However, what's lacking here in most respects is easy to fill in from what we know of the time and place, and because the acting is so good. It's also well-directed, despite a few moments of incredulity, and the necessity for either a leaner edit with respect to the action aspects of the movie, or a longer cut with regards to what it's lacking. Unfortunately, it sits in the middle with jarring interruptions that are well-meaning, but this is a film in need of better focus.
Miss Peregrine`s Home for Peculiar Children is less about Miss Peregrine than a young boy who is lead to her by stories his late grandfather told him. Stories about children with peculiarities, or extraordinary gifts that makes them unique and individual. Which has shades of X-Men on the surface, but this being a Tim Burton film means that it's rich with oddity and invention. Although the story is pretty straightforward, except for the complications that come, quite naturally, with a time travelling narrative. Miss Peregrine`s home is found in a 1942 time loop, which the young boy, played by Asa Butterfield, sets out to discover, much to his father's bemusement.
This isn't Burton on prime form, and it's not quite as dark as his best work, but he creates an inviting premise from a script that's akin to Alice in Wonderland, complete with jeopardy in the form of Samuel L. Jackson`s villain of the piece. And it's a great looking movie, with wonderful costume design and peculiar characters. There's also some nice animated sequences here, too. And a great nod to Jason and the Argonauts. I really enjoyed this movie. It's not the most original film Burton has made. But it's a good fantasy adventure.