MACCA's Birthday!
Moderators: Moderator5, Moderator3, FECC-Moderator, londonflash, Site Mechanic
-
Topic author - Posts: 11323
- Registered for: 13 years 2 months
- Location: Cali
- Has thanked: 2717 times
- Been thanked: 1200 times
- Contact:
MACCA's Birthday!
Paul is 72 today. Happy birthday.
Now to a question. The one song I always - well, hated, was "Eleanor Rigby." Morbid. Pointless.
What do you think?
Paul McCartney - Eleanor Rigby - In Performance A…:
..
rjm
Sent via mobile
Now to a question. The one song I always - well, hated, was "Eleanor Rigby." Morbid. Pointless.
What do you think?
Paul McCartney - Eleanor Rigby - In Performance A…:
..
rjm
Sent via mobile
Last edited by rjm on Sat Jun 21, 2014 12:34 am, edited 1 time in total.
"And even in our sleep pain that cannot forget falls drop by drop upon the heart, and in our own despair, against our will, comes wisdom to us by the awful grace of God."
Aeschylus
"Treat me mean and cruel, treat me like a fool, but love me!"
My Tumblr blog: https://robinmark64.tumblr.com/
https://www.youtube.com/user/robinmark64
Aeschylus
"Treat me mean and cruel, treat me like a fool, but love me!"
My Tumblr blog: https://robinmark64.tumblr.com/
https://www.youtube.com/user/robinmark64
-
- Posts: 107314
- Registered for: 21 years
- Location: United States of America
- Has thanked: 11753 times
- Been thanked: 34078 times
- Age: 89
Re: MACCA's Birthday!
"Eleanor Rigby" is an amazing recording, especially when you consider that Paul was just 23 when he recorded it with the Beatles.rjm wrote:Paul is 71 today. Happy birthday.
Now to a question. The one song I always - well, hated, was "Eleanor Rigby." Morbid. Pointless.
What do you think?
Paul McCartney - Eleanor Rigby - In Performance A…:
..
Happy Birthday James Paul McCartney! Hope to see you in August at Candlestick Park!!
.
Dr. John Carpenter, M.D.
Stop, look and listen, baby <<--->> that's my philosophy!
Dr. John Carpenter, M.D.
Stop, look and listen, baby <<--->> that's my philosophy!
-
- Posts: 9154
- Registered for: 13 years 10 months
- Location: Germany, pretty close to Bad Nauheim
- Has thanked: 1810 times
- Been thanked: 1154 times
Re: MACCA's Birthday!
Thanks for reminding, Robin!
Happy Birthday Paul!
I also think "Eleanor Rigby" is a marvellous recording, so very unusual. Even like the pure instrumental track.
Yes, morbid it is but not pointless at all. A bit depressing though...
Happy Birthday Paul!
I also think "Eleanor Rigby" is a marvellous recording, so very unusual. Even like the pure instrumental track.
Yes, morbid it is but not pointless at all. A bit depressing though...
When the evening shadows fall
And you're wondering who to call
For a little company
There's always me
And you're wondering who to call
For a little company
There's always me
-
Topic author - Posts: 11323
- Registered for: 13 years 2 months
- Location: Cali
- Has thanked: 2717 times
- Been thanked: 1200 times
- Contact:
Re: MACCA's Birthday!
Somebody explain it to me, so as to convince of the point.
rjm
Sent via mobile
rjm
Sent via mobile
"And even in our sleep pain that cannot forget falls drop by drop upon the heart, and in our own despair, against our will, comes wisdom to us by the awful grace of God."
Aeschylus
"Treat me mean and cruel, treat me like a fool, but love me!"
My Tumblr blog: https://robinmark64.tumblr.com/
https://www.youtube.com/user/robinmark64
Aeschylus
"Treat me mean and cruel, treat me like a fool, but love me!"
My Tumblr blog: https://robinmark64.tumblr.com/
https://www.youtube.com/user/robinmark64
Re: MACCA's Birthday!
Why? If you don't like it, you don't like it, what can anybody tell you that's suddenly going to make you listen to it and think "Oh yes, I was wrong all those other two hundred times."rjm wrote:Somebody explain it to me, so as to convince of the point.
I had this same argument once myself, when I told somebody that I couldn't stand a particular LP. He was convinced that all he had to do was tell me about the artist's struggle to make the record, and the circumstances in which the songs were written, and I'd suddenly 'get it'. In the end I had to say to him, "Look mate, it's a load of crap, end of story. Finding out that his parents were murdered when he was a child and that he was brought up by a pack of wolves isn't going to make me love your poxy favourite album. Get over it."
Eleanor Rigby is one of the greatest records ever made, but if you don't see that now then you probably never will. I have the same problem with 99% of everything that Van Morrison ever recorded, and I could listen to Astral Weeks from now til I die and not change my mind. Apparently I'm the one who is missing out, but I think I can live with that.
-
Topic author - Posts: 11323
- Registered for: 13 years 2 months
- Location: Cali
- Has thanked: 2717 times
- Been thanked: 1200 times
- Contact:
Re: MACCA's Birthday!
But I am curious.
I remember listening to it as a teenager with much less refined tastes, and thinking "what is this for, anyway? To say that he is happy and feels pity for "all the lonely people?" And then asks "where do they all belong?" There's no reasonable answer for that. They belong wherever they choose to belong. Where do they all come from? I learned that in grade school: same as everyone else. Why are they lonely? Paul should ask someone who is lonely. Lotta different reasons.
So you have two utterly lonely people, who come together serendipitously at her funeral, such as it was. "Nobody came." Well, the Father did.
So, a lonely preacher throws dirt on the grave of someone no one cared about. And there are dark strings.
I had no idea what his point was, and still don't. If you love it, there must be some reason. I would like to know what that reason is.
It always made me very depressed, and I didn't get the point of making listeners depressed. I mean, just for the sake of it.
So, if anyone could explain why they like it, I would like that.
rjm
P.S. -- There is a statue of "her" on a bench in Liverpool. So, is she the "unknown soldier of loneliness"? Is that it?
Sent via mobile
I remember listening to it as a teenager with much less refined tastes, and thinking "what is this for, anyway? To say that he is happy and feels pity for "all the lonely people?" And then asks "where do they all belong?" There's no reasonable answer for that. They belong wherever they choose to belong. Where do they all come from? I learned that in grade school: same as everyone else. Why are they lonely? Paul should ask someone who is lonely. Lotta different reasons.
So you have two utterly lonely people, who come together serendipitously at her funeral, such as it was. "Nobody came." Well, the Father did.
So, a lonely preacher throws dirt on the grave of someone no one cared about. And there are dark strings.
I had no idea what his point was, and still don't. If you love it, there must be some reason. I would like to know what that reason is.
It always made me very depressed, and I didn't get the point of making listeners depressed. I mean, just for the sake of it.
So, if anyone could explain why they like it, I would like that.
rjm
P.S. -- There is a statue of "her" on a bench in Liverpool. So, is she the "unknown soldier of loneliness"? Is that it?
Sent via mobile
"And even in our sleep pain that cannot forget falls drop by drop upon the heart, and in our own despair, against our will, comes wisdom to us by the awful grace of God."
Aeschylus
"Treat me mean and cruel, treat me like a fool, but love me!"
My Tumblr blog: https://robinmark64.tumblr.com/
https://www.youtube.com/user/robinmark64
Aeschylus
"Treat me mean and cruel, treat me like a fool, but love me!"
My Tumblr blog: https://robinmark64.tumblr.com/
https://www.youtube.com/user/robinmark64
-
- Posts: 107314
- Registered for: 21 years
- Location: United States of America
- Has thanked: 11753 times
- Been thanked: 34078 times
- Age: 89
Re: MACCA's Birthday!
It's a perfectly composed, beautifully played and arranged song of sadness about the human existence.
Or something.
Or something.
.
Dr. John Carpenter, M.D.
Stop, look and listen, baby <<--->> that's my philosophy!
Dr. John Carpenter, M.D.
Stop, look and listen, baby <<--->> that's my philosophy!
Re: MACCA's Birthday!
Happy Birthday, Paul Ramone !!!
I just love those early photos of the band :
17 August 1960 - Wednesday
The Indra
64 Grosse Freiheit
Hamburg, Germany
These are the first photos taken of "THE BEATLES".
George says these were taken the first night of their first trip to Hamburg.
They played at The Indra 17 August - 3 October 1960
***************************
Please, check out this amazing website :
http://www.beatlesource.com/index.html
I just love those early photos of the band :
17 August 1960 - Wednesday
The Indra
64 Grosse Freiheit
Hamburg, Germany
These are the first photos taken of "THE BEATLES".
George says these were taken the first night of their first trip to Hamburg.
They played at The Indra 17 August - 3 October 1960
***************************
Please, check out this amazing website :
http://www.beatlesource.com/index.html
-
- Posts: 5733
- Registered for: 12 years
- Been thanked: 1603 times
Re: MACCA's Birthday!
I like the original because Paul sang it in scouse, which he doesn't nowadays. This is a british thing, which americans won't pick up on.rjm wrote:So, if anyone could explain why they like it, I would like that.
>>>
some people say i done all right for a girl . . . oh yeah yeah
some people say i done all right for a girl . . . oh yeah yeah
-
- Posts: 107314
- Registered for: 21 years
- Location: United States of America
- Has thanked: 11753 times
- Been thanked: 34078 times
- Age: 89
Re: MACCA's Birthday!
Wot?mike edwards66 wrote:I like the original because Paul sang it in scouse, which he doesn't nowadays. This is a british thing, which americans won't pick up on.
Eleanor Rigby picks up the rice in the church where a wedding has BEAN.
.
Dr. John Carpenter, M.D.
Stop, look and listen, baby <<--->> that's my philosophy!
Dr. John Carpenter, M.D.
Stop, look and listen, baby <<--->> that's my philosophy!
-
- Posts: 5733
- Registered for: 12 years
- Been thanked: 1603 times
Re: MACCA's Birthday!
It's true buddy, trust me. To me he now sounds mid-atlantic, nothing wrong with that, he just does.drjohncarpenter wrote:Wot?mike edwards66 wrote:I like the original because Paul sang it in scouse, which he doesn't nowadays. This is a british thing, which americans won't pick up on.
Eleanor Rigby picks up the rice in the church where a wedding has BEAN.
>>>
some people say i done all right for a girl . . . oh yeah yeah
some people say i done all right for a girl . . . oh yeah yeah
-
- Posts: 9154
- Registered for: 13 years 10 months
- Location: Germany, pretty close to Bad Nauheim
- Has thanked: 1810 times
- Been thanked: 1154 times
Re: MACCA's Birthday!
Gosh, that dude was so young when he wrote and composed that song. Must've been the use of drugs or something.
When the evening shadows fall
And you're wondering who to call
For a little company
There's always me
And you're wondering who to call
For a little company
There's always me
-
- Posts: 5733
- Registered for: 12 years
- Been thanked: 1603 times
Re: MACCA's Birthday!
Understandably, your ears are not attuned to the finer nuances of scouse. When he sings Father Mckenzie, he could be a yank.drjohncarpenter wrote:Wot?mike edwards66 wrote:I like the original because Paul sang it in scouse, which he doesn't nowadays. This is a british thing, which americans won't pick up on.
Eleanor Rigby picks up the rice in the church where a wedding has BEAN.
>>>
some people say i done all right for a girl . . . oh yeah yeah
some people say i done all right for a girl . . . oh yeah yeah
-
- Banned
- Posts: 4738
- Registered for: 11 years 8 months
- Has thanked: 244 times
- Been thanked: 1055 times
Re: MACCA's Birthday!
I've never read such rubbish!rjm wrote:But I am curious.
I remember listening to it as a teenager with much less refined tastes, and thinking "what is this for, anyway? To say that he is happy and feels pity for "all the lonely people?" And then asks "where do they all belong?" There's no reasonable answer for that. They belong wherever they choose to belong. Where do they all come from? I learned that in grade school: same as everyone else. Why are they lonely? Paul should ask someone who is lonely. Lotta different reasons.
So you have two utterly lonely people, who come together serendipitously at her funeral, such as it was. "Nobody came." Well, the Father did.
So, a lonely preacher throws dirt on the grave of someone no one cared about. And there are dark strings.
I had no idea what his point was, and still don't. If you love it, there must be some reason. I would like to know what that reason is.
It always made me very depressed, and I didn't get the point of making listeners depressed. I mean, just for the sake of it.
So, if anyone could explain why they like it, I would like that.
rjm
P.S. -- There is a statue of "her" on a bench in Liverpool. So, is she the "unknown soldier of loneliness"? Is that it?
Sent via mobile
It's just a song and a very good one too - great lyrics and melody. It's about a lonely person who has no friends but someone was kind enough to see that person off and showing some compassion. Simple.
In essence, it is something that Paul as just made up. Came up with an idea and made it up as he went along. I think it's a very clever song...
This user is no longer a member. They have either been banned or requested their account to be closed.
-
Topic author - Posts: 11323
- Registered for: 13 years 2 months
- Location: Cali
- Has thanked: 2717 times
- Been thanked: 1200 times
- Contact:
Re: MACCA's Birthday!
"Where do THEY all belong?"
That's the problem, right there. "They."
It's not that she "had no friends"; she had nobody.
Whereas the narrator has a "normal" life without such loneliness. He's popular, happy. Bewildered by all the lonely people. Where do they all come from?
It's very difficult to imagine Lennon writing such a song. Very.
rjm
P.S. -- The Father wasn't being kind; it was his job. He was also one of "them."
Sent via mobile
That's the problem, right there. "They."
It's not that she "had no friends"; she had nobody.
Whereas the narrator has a "normal" life without such loneliness. He's popular, happy. Bewildered by all the lonely people. Where do they all come from?
It's very difficult to imagine Lennon writing such a song. Very.
rjm
P.S. -- The Father wasn't being kind; it was his job. He was also one of "them."
Sent via mobile
"And even in our sleep pain that cannot forget falls drop by drop upon the heart, and in our own despair, against our will, comes wisdom to us by the awful grace of God."
Aeschylus
"Treat me mean and cruel, treat me like a fool, but love me!"
My Tumblr blog: https://robinmark64.tumblr.com/
https://www.youtube.com/user/robinmark64
Aeschylus
"Treat me mean and cruel, treat me like a fool, but love me!"
My Tumblr blog: https://robinmark64.tumblr.com/
https://www.youtube.com/user/robinmark64
-
- Banned
- Posts: 4738
- Registered for: 11 years 8 months
- Has thanked: 244 times
- Been thanked: 1055 times
Re: MACCA's Birthday!
It's getting silly now. Ok you don't like the song, no need to pan out the lyrics. It's just a made up bunch of lyrics that fit and work out well. You have to understand the art of songwriting...rjm wrote:"Where do THEY all belong?"
That's the problem, right there. "They."
It's not that she "had no friends"; she had nobody.
Whereas the narrator has a "normal" life without such loneliness. He's popular, happy. Bewildered by all the lonely people. Where do they all come from?
It's very difficult to imagine Lennon writing such a song. Very.
rjm
P.S. -- The Father wasn't being kind; it was his job. He was also one of "them."
Sent via mobile
This user is no longer a member. They have either been banned or requested their account to be closed.
-
Topic author - Posts: 11323
- Registered for: 13 years 2 months
- Location: Cali
- Has thanked: 2717 times
- Been thanked: 1200 times
- Contact:
Re: MACCA's Birthday!
Okay. I'll work on that.mysterytrainrideson wrote:It's getting silly now. Ok you don't like the song, no need to pan out the lyrics. It's just a made up bunch of lyrics that fit and work out well. You have to understand the art of songwriting...rjm wrote:"Where do THEY all belong?"
That's the problem, right there. "They."
It's not that she "had no friends"; she had nobody.
Whereas the narrator has a "normal" life without such loneliness. He's popular, happy. Bewildered by all the lonely people. Where do they all come from?
It's very difficult to imagine Lennon writing such a song. Very.
rjm
P.S. -- The Father wasn't being kind; it was his job. He was also one of "them."
Sent via mobile
(We do have some pros here; like to hear what they think.)
rjm
Sent via mobile
"And even in our sleep pain that cannot forget falls drop by drop upon the heart, and in our own despair, against our will, comes wisdom to us by the awful grace of God."
Aeschylus
"Treat me mean and cruel, treat me like a fool, but love me!"
My Tumblr blog: https://robinmark64.tumblr.com/
https://www.youtube.com/user/robinmark64
Aeschylus
"Treat me mean and cruel, treat me like a fool, but love me!"
My Tumblr blog: https://robinmark64.tumblr.com/
https://www.youtube.com/user/robinmark64
-
- Posts: 2864
- Registered for: 12 years 2 months
- Location: Haydock, Merseyside, UK
- Has thanked: 799 times
- Been thanked: 1110 times
- Age: 51
Re: MACCA's Birthday!
I always took it to mean how did the lonely people get to where they are now (i.e. lonely/on their own etc) and will they ever find that somebody or something to make it all seem worthwhile (from the observers point of view) before they shuffle off this mortal coil, in a similar kind of sense as 'There but for Fortune' as sung by Joan Baez. In 'Eleanor Rigby' it seems not...rjm wrote:Okay. I'll work on that.mysterytrainrideson wrote:It's getting silly now. Ok you don't like the song, no need to pan out the lyrics. It's just a made up bunch of lyrics that fit and work out well. You have to understand the art of songwriting...rjm wrote:"Where do THEY all belong?"
That's the problem, right there. "They."
It's not that she "had no friends"; she had nobody.
Whereas the narrator has a "normal" life without such loneliness. He's popular, happy. Bewildered by all the lonely people. Where do they all come from?
It's very difficult to imagine Lennon writing such a song. Very.
rjm
P.S. -- The Father wasn't being kind; it was his job. He was also one of "them."
Sent via mobile
(We do have some pros here; like to hear what they think.)
rjm
Sent via mobile
But, hey that's just how I read it...
Well, Good evenin', don't that sun look good goin' down...
-
- Banned
- Posts: 4738
- Registered for: 11 years 8 months
- Has thanked: 244 times
- Been thanked: 1055 times
Re: MACCA's Birthday!
Bloody cheek!rjm wrote:Okay. I'll work on that.mysterytrainrideson wrote:It's getting silly now. Ok you don't like the song, no need to pan out the lyrics. It's just a made up bunch of lyrics that fit and work out well. You have to understand the art of songwriting...rjm wrote:"Where do THEY all belong?"
That's the problem, right there. "They."
It's not that she "had no friends"; she had nobody.
Whereas the narrator has a "normal" life without such loneliness. He's popular, happy. Bewildered by all the lonely people. Where do they all come from?
It's very difficult to imagine Lennon writing such a song. Very.
rjm
P.S. -- The Father wasn't being kind; it was his job. He was also one of "them."
Sent via mobile
(We do have some pros here; like to hear what they think.)
rjm
Sent via mobile
The chorus goes:
"All the lonely people where do they all come from?"
"All the lonely people where do they all belong?"
It's meaning is people like Eleanor Rigby. I don't know if you've worked it out or not but there is more then one lonely person in this world, but
where do they all come from?...and where do they
all belong?...is what he is saying.
Last edited by mysterytrainrideson on Mon Jun 23, 2014 4:52 pm, edited 1 time in total.
This user is no longer a member. They have either been banned or requested their account to be closed.
Re: MACCA's Birthday!
I can see your point, rjm.
To be honest, I don't hate the song, but it's not one of my favourites either. I find it not just morbid, but pompous. Too arty, if you ask me.
I have transcribed for you the "Eleanor Rigby" chapter from Ian MacDonald's great book "Revolution In The Head: The Beatles' Records And The Sixties". I hope you find it interesting. You can also visit the "Eleanor Rigby" page in "The Beatles Bible" website. The link is at the end of this post:
http://www.beatlesbible.com/songs/eleanor-rigby/
To be honest, I don't hate the song, but it's not one of my favourites either. I find it not just morbid, but pompous. Too arty, if you ask me.
I have transcribed for you the "Eleanor Rigby" chapter from Ian MacDonald's great book "Revolution In The Head: The Beatles' Records And The Sixties". I hope you find it interesting. You can also visit the "Eleanor Rigby" page in "The Beatles Bible" website. The link is at the end of this post:
Death is a subject normally avoided in pop music. Where acknowledged, it is either sanitised with heavenly choirs or treated as a black joke (e.g., The Shangri-La's camp 1965 classic “Leader Of The Pack”). Consequently the downbeat demise of a lonely spinster in “Eleanor Rigby” - not to mention the brutal image of the priest “wiping the dirt from his hands as he walks from the grave” - came as quite a shock to pop listeners in 1966. Taken together with George Martin's wintry string octet arrangement, the impact was transfixing.
In fact, the song's grim final verse was settled on only after much head-scratching and at the last minute. According to McCartney, “Eleanor Rigby” began as a plain tune with a melancholy descending phrase and the image of a spinster, Miss Daisy Hawkins, sweeping up the rice in a church after a marriage. Meeting Jane Asher in Bristol, where she was working in rep, McCartney allegedly got the name Rigby from a clothes shop, adding “Eleanor” from Eleanor Bron, the actress who had played the female lead in “Help!”. Against this is the fact that the Rigbys were a well-known local family in Liverpool, of whom one, Eleanor (1895-1939), lies buried in the churchyard of St. Peter's in Woolton, close to McCartney's home suburb of Allerton.
Armed with only the first verse, McCartney headed for Lennon's house at Weybridge where, during an informal evening with friends, he and the other Beatles pieced the rest of the song together. Starting as Father McCartney, the priest in the second verse soon became the more neutral Father McKenzie, a name found by consulting a telephone directory. Starr suggested the idea of him “darning his socks in the night”. The refrain “Ah look at all the lonely people” seems to have been designed by committee, possibly later in the studio (where some say the last verse was decided); others maintain that the song was completed during the same evening. (Lennon, who subsequently claimed “about 70 per cent” of the lyric, apparently tried to quash the idea of its two characters “meeting” at the end).
Given its chaotic genesis, “Eleanor Rigby” is extraordinarily cogent and concentrated. The face that the heroine “keeps in a jar by the door” (to mask the despair inadmissible by English middle-class etiquette) remains the single most memorable image in The Beatles' output. Yet the lyric's televisual vividness (“Look at him working”) is never gratuitous, being consistently at the service of the song's relentless despondency. Eleanor Rigby dies alone because unable to tell anyone how she felt. McKenzie's sermon won't be heard – not that he cares very much about his parishioners - because religious faith has perished along with communal spirit (“No one was saved”). Often represented as purveyors of escapist fantasy, The Beatles were, at their best, more poignantly realistic about their society than any other popular artist of their time.
The monochrome pessimism of the lyric is paralleled in the naked sinplicity of the music : a plain E Dorian melody over what amounts to two chords. Arranged by Martin from a rough idea by McCartney, the string accompaniment was recorded along with a guide vocal in a standard three-hour session, the final vocals being added later. Issued as a single (coupled with “Yellow Submarine”), “Eleanor Rigby” held the UK No. 1 spot for four weeks during August and September. (The comparatively hollow “Paperback Writer” lasted only two weeks at the top). In militantly optimistic America, however, the combination fared less well, “Yellow Submarine's” light relief proving more popular. Neither reached the top of the chart.
http://www.beatlesbible.com/songs/eleanor-rigby/
-
Topic author - Posts: 11323
- Registered for: 13 years 2 months
- Location: Cali
- Has thanked: 2717 times
- Been thanked: 1200 times
- Contact:
Re: MACCA's Birthday!
Thanks, Mister Moon. You know, I never read a review. These are just my own thoughts.
And if it's "bloody cheek" that I've got, so be it!
(Hoping I know what that means.)
rjm
Sent via mobile
And if it's "bloody cheek" that I've got, so be it!
(Hoping I know what that means.)
rjm
Sent via mobile
"And even in our sleep pain that cannot forget falls drop by drop upon the heart, and in our own despair, against our will, comes wisdom to us by the awful grace of God."
Aeschylus
"Treat me mean and cruel, treat me like a fool, but love me!"
My Tumblr blog: https://robinmark64.tumblr.com/
https://www.youtube.com/user/robinmark64
Aeschylus
"Treat me mean and cruel, treat me like a fool, but love me!"
My Tumblr blog: https://robinmark64.tumblr.com/
https://www.youtube.com/user/robinmark64
-
- Posts: 5733
- Registered for: 12 years
- Been thanked: 1603 times
Re: MACCA's Birthday!
Wow.mysterytrainrideson wrote:The chorus goes:
"All the lonely people where do they all come from?"
"All the lonely people where do they all belong?"
where do they all come from?...and where do they
all belong?...is what he is saying.
>>>
some people say i done all right for a girl . . . oh yeah yeah
some people say i done all right for a girl . . . oh yeah yeah