Tue Apr 24, 2007 7:29 am
Robt wrote:It's an incredible version ... even if it was an audience recording).
Robt wrote:Question Doc: How do you rate Elvis' marvelous rendition on "America the beautiful?"
Cryogenic wrote:drjohncarpenter wrote:It was not an award, little Monique Brave gave Elvis a MOST ironic gift backstage in Rapid City -- a sacred, Sioux Nation "Medallion of Life."
In your ignorance / haste to denigrate EIC further, I see you omitted a crucial fact from your statement: the "Medallion of Life" isn't necessarily ironic ...
Tue Apr 24, 2007 7:48 am
drjohncarpenter wrote:Cryogenic wrote:drjohncarpenter wrote:It was not an award, little Monique Brave gave Elvis a MOST ironic gift backstage in Rapid City -- a sacred, Sioux Nation "Medallion of Life."
In your ignorance / haste to denigrate EIC further, I see you omitted a crucial fact from your statement: the "Medallion of Life" isn't necessarily ironic ...
First of all, you miscategorize my statements, which are neither ignorant nor serving to denigrate. This is purely your own inference. My words are an honest assessment of the darkest moments in the career of Elvis Presley. As for your view on the Sioux Nation "Medallion of Life," I suggest you do a little more research.
Tue Apr 24, 2007 8:14 am
Cryogenic wrote:But perhaps you would like to kick down some additional knowledge that you act like you possess.
Tue Apr 24, 2007 8:18 am
Tue Apr 24, 2007 8:29 am
drjohncarpenter wrote:Cryogenic wrote:But perhaps you would like to kick down some additional knowledge that you act like you possess.
Your condescending tone fails to mask your insecurity, but is not appreciated in any case.
drjohncarpenter wrote:You may twist around definitions of the Sioux "Medallion of Life" all you wish, but the fact that a ten year-old girl gave Elvis Presley such a gift, and he was dead about 57 days later is ironic. Period.
Tue Apr 24, 2007 8:30 am
midnightx wrote: And what is even more incredible is that some fans on this board would rather see EIC in a deluxe form before footage from some of Elvis' prime years as an artist is issued. That is mind-boggling.
Tue Apr 24, 2007 3:58 pm
drjohncarpenter wrote:Certainly, it is clear a minority of hardcore fans want a release of the train wreck that was the October 1977 CBS-TV Special.
Tue Apr 24, 2007 4:34 pm
drjohncarpenter wrote:You may twist around definitions of the Sioux "Medallion of Life" all you wish, but the fact that a ten year-old girl gave Elvis Presley such a gift, and he was dead about 57 days later is ironic. Period.
See ya!
Tue Apr 24, 2007 4:37 pm
Steve_M wrote:.....there is a monority that want the original broaadcast version.
Tue Apr 24, 2007 5:45 pm
Tue Apr 24, 2007 6:19 pm
Steve_M wrote:Lew Nyack wrote:Steve_M wrote:.....there is a monority that want the original broaadcast version.
Who are these people??? Come forward!
I say they should be publicly flogged.
People ? See, you do know more than you're letting on. I wasn't confident it was plural.
Tue Apr 24, 2007 8:39 pm
Wed Apr 25, 2007 12:11 am
Robt wrote:Fellas, please can you resolve your non-Elvis debate regarding some indian american mythology ...
Robt wrote:... i am an Australian and it follows that i do not know the original lyrics of AMERICA THE BEAUTIFUL.
Robt wrote:I very much look forward to in future either on the messageboard or in private, of drawing on your remarkable knowledge, either Elvis or other artists. You are a rock scholar and this should be commended!
Doc tell me another artiste who recorded a version of it say in the 1960's and 1970's with all of it's lyrics? I'd love to try to find a copy one day?
ALL POWER TO YOU DOC!
Robt wrote:... howcome he made a point of performing this from Dec 1975 and carried on almost exclusively throughout 1976?
Robt wrote:there was a possibility that the concert that came out as GOODBYE MEMPHIS which featured "America" was to have been a RCA 1976 live record that mysteriously got ditched. Got any theories Doc as to why it was cancelled?
Wed Apr 25, 2007 1:16 am
Wed Apr 25, 2007 1:40 am
Robt wrote:I am NOT an Elvis purists/completist. It is not economical to be ... which as i'm sure you can appreciate takes some considerable time and effort.
Robt wrote:When i write that Elvis performed "America the beautiful" almost exclusively throughout 1976, then it follows, i can't possibly had known how many times he exactly did the song ...
Robt wrote:you say 90 times WOW! As a matter of interest which rendition of AMERICA do you rate out of all 90 performances?
Robt wrote:I am sure that Elvis 90 performances and earlier studio attempts of cutting a master ... is an indication that he tried to come up with a qualityperformance, either live or in the studio, for a commercial project.
Robt wrote:GOODBYE MEMPHIS ... I have precise recollection of Elvis stating to the audience that "the show was being recorded live..." which suggests that there were initial plans to have another live collection of concert material commercially released, not unreasonable considering the
sales of the previous ALOHA and classic M.S.G records sold high enough for the then RCA Victor label to want another shot at it!
Robt wrote:How can we be sure that only a soundboard of this historical performance was the only one that was taped?
Wed Apr 25, 2007 2:49 am
Wed Apr 25, 2007 4:56 am
drjohncarpenter wrote:It doesn't follow.
You need to make such things clear when you post a query.
There are no mindreaders here ... save Colin B.
Wed Apr 25, 2007 7:34 am
N880EP wrote:Hi "Greg",Gregory Nolan Jr. wrote:I would like to think that we're all speaking in good faith, in that we all care greatly about the Elvis Presley legacy. I know a veiled, below-the-radar attempt to settle an old score when I see it. Let it die already. Reasonable people can agree to disagree here ...
You're wrong, because it's just a simple statement of FACT.
Nothing more, other than in your own mind.Gregory Nolan Jr. wrote:For the record, as for your quote, which I like as well, you probably didn't realize it but that was not the actual "Rockin' Rebel" based in the UK (who Steve M. received his CBS tapes from) but rather a newbie who dropped the apostrophe and boldly posts here lately.
You're also wrong here, too. I'm not confusing the two, .......... but thanks anyway.
--------------------------
Music is subjective folks, ............... get over it; some people actually do like EIC & the '77 Elvis.
N8
drjohncarpenter wrote:Certainly, it is clear a minority of hardcore fans want a release of the train wreck that was the October 1977 CBS-TV Special.
But what is unfathomable is how fervent their desire is, in lieu of all the other possible film or video that still awaits a high-quality official release:
- remaining 1956 TV shows (Dorsey-Berle-Allen)
- live footage from 1956-57
- interview footage from 1956-57-58-60
- Sinatra's 1960 Timex Special, "Welcome Home Elvis"
- candid footage 1955-1959
- Hollywood outtake footage 1960-1969
- candid footage 1960-1969
- Las Vegas 1969-1976
- more "TTWII" outtakes (1970)
- on tour 1970-1976
- "Elvis On Tour" outtakes (1972)
- candid footage 1970-1977
Let's get all of this out first, and then even I will sign up for an official release of "Elvis In Concert."
Wed Apr 25, 2007 8:13 am
Gregory Nolan Jr. wrote:That's the same old nasty commentary from the would-be Aristotle of FECC, one "N880," in bold, no less. Here, we see him pretending not to recall how over-the-top he has been known to get on this forum...At least DJC has been known to keep his tongue firmly in cheek when he's in high form.
We all disagree here from time to time but to pompously throw around the word "fallacy" (his favorite word) would result in real life with a punch being thrown. We disagree here often and that's what it makes it tick. Pretending to possess "facts" here is for the most part arrogant when it pertains to discussions based on instincts, feelings, and conjecture. Little here is hard science.
We do agree that music is subjective, naturally.
Gregory Nolan Jr. wrote:That's the same old nasty commentary from the would-be Aristotle of FECC, one "N880," in bold, no less.
Gregory Nolan Jr. wrote:Here, we see him pretending not to recall how over-the-top he has been known to get on this forum...At least DJC has been known to keep his tongue firmly in cheek when he's in high form.
Gregory Nolan Jr. wrote:We all disagree here from time to time but to pompously throw around the word "fallacy" (his favorite word) would result in real life with a punch being thrown. We disagree here often and that's what it makes it tick.
Gregory Nolan Jr. wrote:Pretending to possess "facts" here is for the most part arrogant when it pertains to discussions based on instincts, feelings, and conjecture. Little here is hard science.
Gregory Nolan Jr. wrote:We do agree that music is subjective, naturally.
Wed Apr 25, 2007 8:43 am
Gregory Nolan Jr. wrote:I've always very much enjoyed portions of EIC, for the record. But release it officially? I could live without it that extra pixel of Elvis' sweat and make-up.
Wed Apr 25, 2007 8:48 am
Wed Apr 25, 2007 8:57 am
This is as fallacious as all the stuff that N8 just highlighted. I could easily flip this reductionist comment around and get you to apply it to the Comeback Special or the Ed Sullvian shows -- but wait, we actually HAVE those in good quality as official releases, don't we? And just because you could live without EIC being given the care and respect it deserves, it doesn't mean other people can or should have to. EIC is a critical piece of the tapestry. It is owed its due.
Wed Apr 25, 2007 8:57 am
Gregory Nolan Jr. wrote:"N880" (your real name, too, presumably?)
You remain the snide sort you have continually shown yourself to be when you want to pick a fight. I don't truck in the world of insulting people's education nor showing how "smart" I am.
To my knowledge, you were told to cool it awhile ago after a similiar display of personal attacks, and either were booted or you left in a huff for this same old native nastiness you possess. That's what I refer to, for the uninitiated.
I contend that you indeed are pompous for trotting out your rhetoric lessons on an Elvis messageboard.
Testosterone? I continually wave the flag of peace here (for those who might remember, be it DJC or Genesim in past feuds) and merely ask you to take it down a notch with your over-the-top "I'm right and you're wrong" stand. I'm not even sure we disagree all that much, but you have taken offense that I posted shot of Elvis looking subpar in '77. You have to come to grips with that sad aspect of his decline and stop attacking anyone who points it out.
We could show off our respective reasoning skills until the cows come home, but until then,
Sayonara! :wink:
Wed Apr 25, 2007 9:01 am
Gregory Nolan Jr. wrote:Don't expect rationality to rule: it never will.
Wed Apr 25, 2007 9:04 am
I stand in awe of your fallacious skills with every post you make, "Greg."
Truly, ....... an incredible display to watch.
N8
PS - Unko-tare back to you, too. (wink!)
Hosted by ElviCities