Off Topic Messages


Fri Aug 11, 2006 6:14 pm


Hearing that Mirror Spock was doing a restoration/remaster on AHDN
led me to wonder how much needed to be done and could it be done
successfully enough to warrant such a release? After reading the specs
on what sources were used and how they were done technically, smoke started to come out of my ears, so I won’t go into the many details explained. I will tell you all that I was more than pleasantly surprised in the end product, and find this to be the definitive version that I now own. The visual sources used were the MPI DVD and the Miramax DVD. The songs have been restored to the original mono mixes used in the film (and as he admits EQ’ed for better sound) which now makes watching and listening to the film less jarring than the Miramax stereo mixes of the songs that stood out too noticeably against the mono dialogue. In fact, they still play a bit louder than dialogue in the film, but then again, I’ve never enjoyed the sound recording done on the dialogue which still seems a bit tinny and distant. No fault of Mirror Spock.

The 1982 reissue prologue has been included with “I’ll Cry Instead” in mono. It looks nice. A nice beginning to get you excited about the upcoming start of the feature. Also included is the outtake “You Can’t Do That”, inserted where it was originally cut out of the final print, back at the beginning of the concert at end of movie. It’s quality doesn’t quite match up to the rest of the film visually, but It’s nice to have an additional Beatles performance restored and doesn’t detract from the flow or enjoyment. How can it…? C’mon it’s the Beatles! It’s not a superfluous outtake, but one that fit’s nicely back into the film.

The aspect ratio has been corrected as much as possible with a representation probably the closest to a full-screen presentation with no loss of the top (as with the Miramax DVD)or sides (as with the MPI did). As explained by Mirror Spock, by the creation of this image using these two different aspect ratio sources, some tv’s may leave four black rectangles in the corners of the pictures, but it didn’t happen on my tv. All the better! There is no menu and the DVD immediately starts with the prologue.

Given the few extras that are included, and the restored mono soundtrack (even the amp falling over in “If I Fell”)this is a very enjoyable effort--since it’s closest to the original theatrical presentation available on DVD, I’d have to say this enjoyable effort is essential to own!

Video: 4 out of 5 Stars
Sound: 4 out of 4 Stars
Presentation: 5 out of 5 Stars

Buffalo Wings
aka "Beatle Bob"

Fri Aug 11, 2006 10:35 pm

Another GREAT review! Thanks, Bob! Have you seen the latest two Picture Perfect DVDs, American Tour and Palais?

Fri Aug 11, 2006 10:50 pm

Thanks sir! I do have the latest Picture Perfect titles on their way
to me, hopefully next week (I'm on vacation so that would be perfect timing to sit around and watch them!)and will report on them down
the road.

Have a great weekend and enjoy those Dr. Ebbetts discs :)

Buffalo Wings
aka"Beatle Bob"

Thu Aug 17, 2006 11:15 pm

Please do offer your thoughts on these titles in a fresh topic, when time permits. I enjoy reading what you have to say.