No you don't get it. You assume that the RIAA accreditation correlate to the sum total of Elvis Presley's US album sales. That's a ridiculous position to take and anyone with an ounce of sense could tell you that.brian wrote:
You just don't get it.
RECORD SALES UPDATE?
Moderators: Moderator5, Moderator3, FECC-Moderator, Site Mechanic
Re: RECORD SALES UPDATE?
-
- Posts: 17418
- Registered for: 15 years 10 months
- Has thanked: 190 times
- Been thanked: 3837 times
Re: RECORD SALES UPDATE?
You are a very argumentative person. I wasn't even talking to you my first couple of times posting but since then I feel I've been nice to you in my responses. Yet you keep arguing with me over nothing and you keep blathering on about this and won't let it go. You should apologize for being rude and argumentative.Hard Rocker wrote:No you don't get it. You assume that the RIAA accreditation correlate to the sum total of Elvis Presley's US album sales. That's a ridiculous position to take and anyone with an ounce of sense could tell you that.
Re: RECORD SALES UPDATE?
No, I wont be apologizing. I disagree with your flawed analysis, as would anyone with an inkling of sense.
If you are unhappy with that, then that's Tutt Sheff anyway you wanna look at it.
If you are unhappy with that, then that's Tutt Sheff anyway you wanna look at it.
-
- Posts: 808
- Registered for: 12 years 9 months
- Location: Scotland
- Has thanked: 51 times
- Been thanked: 115 times
Re: RECORD SALES UPDATE?
Posted before somewhere before on FECC and is probably as close to total US albums sales as we'll get. It's from a well respected poster of sales data on various artists.
My guess for US sales would be around 280 million for albums, singles and EP's, based on figures from various posters on the site linked below.
Worldwide?- maybe another 150-200m?
https://www.ukmix.org/forums/viewtopic.php?f=5&t=21747
https://www.ukmix.org/forums/viewtopic.php?f=24&t=42924
My guess for US sales would be around 280 million for albums, singles and EP's, based on figures from various posters on the site linked below.
Worldwide?- maybe another 150-200m?
https://www.ukmix.org/forums/viewtopic.php?f=5&t=21747
https://www.ukmix.org/forums/viewtopic.php?f=24&t=42924
Re: RECORD SALES UPDATE?
Elvis has sold several million albums in the US this past few years according to Soundscan... but he has only received one accreditation since Sept 2011: a Silver Disc for Essential Elvis on March 3, 2016.
Someone might want to explain to our friend Brian that therein lies just one example of why his rationale is totally wide of the mark. Clue: It's got something to do with overall sales outstripping accreditations.
Someone might want to explain to our friend Brian that therein lies just one example of why his rationale is totally wide of the mark. Clue: It's got something to do with overall sales outstripping accreditations.
-
- Posts: 17418
- Registered for: 15 years 10 months
- Has thanked: 190 times
- Been thanked: 3837 times
Re: RECORD SALES UPDATE?
That's not what I have been saying. I do believe Elvis has a few missing sales. Hard Rocker doesn't even understand what I am talking about but that didn't stop him from being the argumentative person that he is.
Re: RECORD SALES UPDATE?
Hard Rocker wrote:Elvis has sold several million albums in the US this past few years according to Soundscan... but he has only received one accreditation since Sept 2011: a Silver Disc for Essential Elvis on March 3, 2016.
Someone might want to explain to our friend Brian that therein lies just one example of why his rationale is totally wide of the mark. Clue: It's got something to do with overall sales outstripping accreditations.
Silver ??????????? Platinum | March 3, 2016 - Gold | August 4, 2010
-
- Posts: 17418
- Registered for: 15 years 10 months
- Has thanked: 190 times
- Been thanked: 3837 times
Re: RECORD SALES UPDATE?
Yes. Silver is a sale certification in the U.K. for sales of 200,000. So it's seems the man made a mistake because Soundscan is for the U.S. and Canada.
-
- Posts: 1197
- Registered for: 12 years 4 months
- Has thanked: 2 times
- Been thanked: 471 times
Re: RECORD SALES UPDATE?
That's actually not true - in the first instance the RIAA only certify whole millions and don't count numbers between certification levels - as Elvis has over 80 plus certified albums that might be a fair number unaccounted for and that's a lot more albums by way of comparison to others .brian wrote:Elvis' album sales in the U.S. don't exceed 136 million until his record label submits proper sales documentation to the RIAA to get more sales upgrades. Until then the only album sales he has are 136 million. That's fact. Any figure that you say that he has sold that's higher than the 136 million that's been documented would be speculation on your part.
There s also the issue of of some 250 plus uncertified albums and numbers are known for some of them.
But be that as it may, I can't claim to be very knowledge in this area and am only passing on information I have read elsewhere.
some interesting reads are on these blogs and they don't seem to have been updated for several years now.
https://www.ukmix.org/forums/viewtopic.php?f=24&t=42924&sid=00d30a41ef5bddb063f8f12649f9385d
http://www.elvisinfonet.com/spotlight_tonygalvin.html
Re: RECORD SALES UPDATE?
brian wrote:Yes. Silver is a sale certification in the U.K. for sales of 200,000. So it's seems the man made a mistake because Soundscan is for the U.S. and Canada.
Silver in UK is 60.000 Gold 100.000 Platinum 300.000 (Album)
Singel is 200.000 Gold 400.000 Platinum 600.000
Re: RECORD SALES UPDATE?
I stand corrected on that however the principle of my point remains undiminished. Presley's sales have outstripped his awards since Sept 2011 and this is why we cannot accept that his US album sales total is the same as the RIAA figure for awards.kriss wrote:Hard Rocker wrote:Elvis has sold several million albums in the US this past few years according to Soundscan... but he has only received one accreditation since Sept 2011: a Silver Disc for Essential Elvis on March 3, 2016.
Someone might want to explain to our friend Brian that therein lies just one example of why his rationale is totally wide of the mark. Clue: It's got something to do with overall sales outstripping accreditations.
Silver ??????????? Platinum | March 3, 2016 - Gold | August 4, 2010
Re: RECORD SALES UPDATE?
Finally, someone talks sense. Thanks for that!FredAistair wrote:That's actually not true - in the first instance the RIAA only certify whole millions and don't count numbers between certification levels - as Elvis has over 80 plus certified albums that might be a fair number unaccounted for and that's a lot more albums by way of comparison to others .brian wrote:Elvis' album sales in the U.S. don't exceed 136 million until his record label submits proper sales documentation to the RIAA to get more sales upgrades. Until then the only album sales he has are 136 million. That's fact. Any figure that you say that he has sold that's higher than the 136 million that's been documented would be speculation on your part.
There s also the issue of of some 250 plus uncertified albums and numbers are known for some of them.
l
Re: RECORD SALES UPDATE?
Exactly!Hard Rocker wrote:I stand corrected on that however the principle of my point remains undiminished. Presley's sales have outstripped his awards since Sept 2011 and this is why we cannot accept that his US album sales total is the same as the RIAA figure for awards.kriss wrote:Hard Rocker wrote:Elvis has sold several million albums in the US this past few years according to Soundscan... but he has only received one accreditation since Sept 2011: a Silver Disc for Essential Elvis on March 3, 2016.
Someone might want to explain to our friend Brian that therein lies just one example of why his rationale is totally wide of the mark. Clue: It's got something to do with overall sales outstripping accreditations.
Silver ??????????? Platinum | March 3, 2016 - Gold | August 4, 2010
-
- Posts: 17418
- Registered for: 15 years 10 months
- Has thanked: 190 times
- Been thanked: 3837 times
Re: RECORD SALES UPDATE?
I know all of this you can't expect them to count sales that are in between levels like that because those numbers are hard to track. There has to be sales thresholds that you have to meet. The RIAA does the same thing with other artists. As for the claim of 250 uncertified albums well Sony better get cracking then. Until then Elvis' tally stands at 136 million.FredAistair wrote:That's actually not true - in the first instance the RIAA only certify whole millions and don't count numbers between certification levels - as Elvis has over 80 plus certified albums that might be a fair number unaccounted for and that's a lot more albums by way of comparison to others .
There s also the issue of of some 250 plus uncertified albums and numbers are known for some of them.
-
- Posts: 16747
- Registered for: 21 years
- Location: Canada
- Has thanked: 3975 times
- Been thanked: 5511 times
- Age: 89
Re: RECORD SALES UPDATE?
brian wrote:It's the truth. People in Elvis' era didn't sell that many records but they continue to spout such ridiculous claims. Elvis has 201 million certified sales by the RIAA if you count albums, singles and Extended plays. Jerry Lee Lewis, Ricky Nelson and The Four Seasons etc. would have loved to have 201 million sales. There is no was way Elvis' label could ever come up with the sales data to back up 1.5 billion because he didn't sell that much. In truth there isn't over 1 billion missing sales left unaccounted for. All the RIAA does is certify and then hand out awards after record labels provide them with proof of sales.elvis-fan wrote:lol... that's funny... I spit out some of my cereal when I read that this morning... thanks for that!brian wrote:Elvis' RIAA tallies are more realistic and more accurate than people realize or give them credit for...
-
- Posts: 1197
- Registered for: 12 years 4 months
- Has thanked: 2 times
- Been thanked: 471 times
Re: RECORD SALES UPDATE?
1. What is it that you don't get that Elvis has significantly more certified albums than other artists that effect him adversely in comparison in respect of the RIAA figures.brian wrote:I know all of this you can't expect them to count sales that are in between levels like that because those numbers are hard to track. There has to be sales thresholds that you have to meet. The RIAA does the same thing with other artists. As for the claim of 250 uncertified albums well Sony better get cracking then. Until then Elvis' tally stands at 136 million.FredAistair wrote:That's actually not true - in the first instance the RIAA only certify whole millions and don't count numbers between certification levels - as Elvis has over 80 plus certified albums that might be a fair number unaccounted for and that's a lot more albums by way of comparison to others .
There s also the issue of of some 250 plus uncertified albums and numbers are known for some of them.
2. What is it that you don't get that certified sales by the RIAA and actual sales for any artists are two different things.
3. And what is it that you don't get that 250 plus un-certified albums would cumulatively have significant sales attached to them.
4. The other things you do get though!
-
- Posts: 17418
- Registered for: 15 years 10 months
- Has thanked: 190 times
- Been thanked: 3837 times
Re: RECORD SALES UPDATE?
To answer Fred Astair's questions.
1. As I said I don't blame the RIAA for not tracking sales for albums in between sales cerftifications. Perhaps Elvis' label shouldn't have ridiculously flooded the market. That is their own fault and too damn bad.
2. I get it. what you and Hard Rocker don't understand is that no one knows for sure how many records Elvis has sold. All you can go by is his documented sales. Anything after that is speculation.
3. Not necessarily most of those releases may not have sold enough to get a gold award. That again is speculation unless Sony gets the sales paperwork together to submit to the RIAA. It's hard to say.
4. Thank you.
1. As I said I don't blame the RIAA for not tracking sales for albums in between sales cerftifications. Perhaps Elvis' label shouldn't have ridiculously flooded the market. That is their own fault and too damn bad.
2. I get it. what you and Hard Rocker don't understand is that no one knows for sure how many records Elvis has sold. All you can go by is his documented sales. Anything after that is speculation.
3. Not necessarily most of those releases may not have sold enough to get a gold award. That again is speculation unless Sony gets the sales paperwork together to submit to the RIAA. It's hard to say.
4. Thank you.
-
- Posts: 1197
- Registered for: 12 years 4 months
- Has thanked: 2 times
- Been thanked: 471 times
Re: RECORD SALES UPDATE?
RIAA sales are those for those someone has produced supporting documents for that meet their rules and paid the fees.brian wrote:To answer Fred Astair's questions.
1. As I said I don't blame the RIAA for not tracking sales for albums in between sales cerftifications. Perhaps Elvis' label shouldn't have ridiculously flooded the market. That is their own fault and too damn bad.
2. I get it. what you and Hard Rocker don't understand is that no one knows for sure how many records Elvis has sold. All you can go by is his documented sales. Anything after that is speculation.
3. Not necessarily most of those releases may not have sold enough to get a gold award. That again is speculation unless Sony gets the sales paperwork together to submit to the RIAA. It's hard to say.
4. Thank you.
The are no more than that, so no they do not by any means reflect the true sales for any anyone beyond those parameters.
Re: RECORD SALES UPDATE?
Elvis hit over 1 billion worldwide sales in 1982. Look it up. Also, the Guinness Book Of World Records has Elvis as the best selling artist of all time with over 1 billion sales, what are you some of you talking about??? There are many Elvis sales that unfortunately are unaccounted for. http://www.guinnessworldrecords.com/world-records/best-selling-solo-artist
“Don’t criticize what you don’t understand, son. You never walked in that man’s shoes.”
― Elvis Presley
― Elvis Presley
Re: RECORD SALES UPDATE?
No-one disputes that his RIAA tally is 136 million. We are aware of that.brian wrote:
I know all of this you can't expect them to count sales that are in between levels like that because those numbers are hard to track. There has to be sales thresholds that you have to meet. The RIAA does the same thing with other artists. As for the claim of 250 uncertified albums well Sony better get cracking then. Until then Elvis' tally stands at 136 million.
What we have been disputing (and what you have been denying) is that his sales outstrip his certifications.
However.... the maths have proven you wrong. There is no argument here. This is not about opinion. You simply talked yourself into a hole and you have now realized it.
-
- Posts: 17418
- Registered for: 15 years 10 months
- Has thanked: 190 times
- Been thanked: 3837 times
Re: RECORD SALES UPDATE?
Moving on does anyone know what Elvis' ''certified'' singles and album sales are in the U.K., Australia and Canada?
Re: RECORD SALES UPDATE?
Good idea. Next time, don't be too hasty when it comes to demanding undue apologies.brian wrote:Moving on
Have a nice day.
-
- Posts: 17418
- Registered for: 15 years 10 months
- Has thanked: 190 times
- Been thanked: 3837 times
Re: RECORD SALES UPDATE?
Except for the fact that many years ago all the record labels in America got together and they decided that the RIAA would be the only organization in the U.S. that would tally sales and hand out official certifications. There is nothing else to go on because after that decision record labels stopped making in house sales awards for their own artists. Elvis' label actually did a good job in getting his sales updated as much as they did. If they didn't do that and there was no organization to hand out awards we would have a less clearer picture of what he has sold and he would receive less credit for his sales.FredAistair wrote:RIAA sales are those for those someone has produced supporting documents for that meet their rules and paid the fees.
The are no more than that, so no they do not by any means reflect the true sales for any anyone beyond those parameters.
-
- Posts: 17418
- Registered for: 15 years 10 months
- Has thanked: 190 times
- Been thanked: 3837 times
Re: RECORD SALES UPDATE?
Even Hard Rocker does not believe that. Don't be so gullible. If I told you Elvis had sold 1 trillion records by 1986 would you believe it.EPFan1970 wrote:Elvis hit over 1 billion worldwide sales in 1982.